Caption That Cover: How Much is Too Much?

We haven’t had a caption contest in a hot minute! This cover was sent in by Jen, who had this to say:

There are just no words to describe how bonkers this looks.

Prehistorical One Horned Menage by Stix Hiscock. A collage of 3D models. There's a mermaid on a motorcycle with a sub sandwich. She's about to back up over a garden gnome. There's also a white unicorn in the background and a shirtless man with a dinosaur head.

Very Chuck Tingle-esque, don’t you think?

Comment below with your caption! Caption that cover however you wish! You can come up with a new title or tagline. A winner will be randomly selected at the end of the contest!

The best captioner will receive a $10 bookstore credit to a book retailer of their choosing.

Standard disclaimers apply: We are not being compensated for this giveaway. Void where prohibited. Open to international residents where permitted by applicable law. Must be over 18. Regardless of the mermaid above, please practice motorcycle safety and wear you helmets. Comments will close Friday, October 21, 2022 around noon ET, and a winner will be announced shortly thereafter.

Good luck!

The winning caption comes from Deborah:

Stop me if you’ve heard this one before: a unicorn, a brontotaur, and a mermaid walk into a biker bar and the garden gnome behind the bar says…

Comments are Closed

  1. DiscoDollyDeb says:

    Garden gnome with the thousand-yard stare: “You won’t believe the things I’ve seen…and participated in.”

  2. MirandaB says:

    Ya’ll figure it out and let me know. I’m gonna eat.

  3. Jaye says:

    The real reason “Have It Your Way” was discontinued.

  4. Empress of Blandings says:

    Book characters (glancing round to make sure author is out of earshot): ‘Sennnndddd helllllpppp’.

  5. Katy L says:

    We’re all this and a bag of chips. Wait, we don’t have any chips – OK, who forgot the chips?

  6. Maggie says:

    Microdosing be damned: Inside Stix Hiscock’s last, best acid trip

  7. Deborah says:

    Stop me if you’ve heard this one before: a unicorn, a brontotaur, and a mermaid walk into a biker bar and the garden gnome behind the bar says…

  8. Charlotte says:

    (with apologies to the Everly Brothers)

    “Whenever I want you, all I have to do is
    Dream, dream, dream, dream”

  9. AtasB says:

    “I can’t believe I forgot the dash!” – cover designer’s only regret

  10. Todd says:

    Too much of a good thing … is not this cover.

  11. Laura says:

    Clip art for beginners!

  12. Laurel K. says:

    Is she planning on eating that burger the size of her head or is it an offering for bronto-dude?

  13. MelMc says:

    In my head-canon this is a m/m book about the unicorn and the dino-guy. The mermaid is the wacky roommate who unintentionally interupts all their intimate moments because of her constant motorcycle accidents. (insert ALL the fish on a bicycle jokes here). The gnome is her motorcycle instructor (little dude is obviously traumatized)

  14. MaryK says:

    When your cat sits on your keyboard while you’re in Photoshop.

  15. MsCellanie says:

    “Got it! For the next set of commercials we send the Roaming Gnome to the Island of Dr. Moreau. He goes motorcyling, he sees some landscapes, he has an orgy… you know, whatever. The print campaign is a collage of all his adventures.”
    “It’ll be amazing.”

  16. Denise says:

    EVERYBODY IN THE POOL!!!!!

  17. rose says:

    I wasn’t sure if that was a sub sandwich, but it’s my favorite part of this hahahaha

  18. tiago 5 says:

    Can we comment on the author’s name? Stix His Cock. Really author!? What a name. Some one clearly thinks they are a very amusing person. As for the caption……. ” Not today Thingys, Not.To. Day.”

  19. Debbie Dashoff says:

    Every sandwich for every BODY. Free delivery

  20. Katta says:

    Prehistoric One Horned Menage—one horn is all it takes

  21. stylinsonbirds says:

    A horny and ROARing good time

    (Is it about the unicorn? motorcycle or the dinos? Who knows)

  22. Karen Lauterwasser says:

    “If I ran the zoo…”. Or maybe “You didn’t lock the gate again!”

  23. EC Spurlock says:

    All the things, all the time.

    Honestly this looks like a bonkers Burger King commercial when the ad department was trying to outdo Old Spice.

  24. Judith Adler says:

    When worlds collide, and collide, and collide.

  25. K says:

    “Get on losers, we’re goin’ catfishin'”

  26. SilverJ says:

    Bronto to gnome waiter: I’ll have a tunacorn on rye with a side of tube steak*. To go.

    *Does anyone younger than me even know that term anymore?

  27. TMary says:

    I don’t have a caption, but I really really really want to be able sing this to the tune of “One-eyed one-horned flying purple people eater”.

  28. spinsterrevival says:

    I know he wasn’t yet around in prehistoric times but…Jesus wept.

  29. Jaer says:

    And this is your book on drugs…

  30. PamG says:

    Welcome to the Kaiju Preservation Society via The Tingleverse.

  31. MegCat says:

    Maybe those mushrooms weren’t the best addition to the burger…

  32. denise says:

    Disney fairy tales gone wild.

  33. Jaws says:

    Tagline for a print ad:

    “One of the few things more disturbing than campaign ads. Even if it is more plausible…”

  34. Kareni says:

    Can you say…BUSY?!

  35. Trix says:

    What does it say about me that my first thought was “what’s on top of that burger bun”?

  36. Trevalou says:

    Everything everywhere all at once, but in a bad way.

  37. SusanE says:

    It’s LL Bean’s new ad for the comfy flannel PJ bottoms that dino guy is wearing.

  38. Muffled says:

    It’s not what you think.

    Look again.

    Got it yet?

    It’s not a hamburger.

    It’s a bagel.

  39. Anony Miss says:

    …still better than the Cats movie.

  40. Zana says:

    gNOme, gNOme..just…gNOOOOOOOme

Comments are closed.

By posting a comment, you consent to have your personally identifiable information collected and used in accordance with our privacy policy.

↑ Back to Top