Book Review

Royal Holiday by Jasmine Guillory

The Royal Holiday by Jasmine Guillory had me smiling from page one and kept me delighted all the way through. My joy was so palpable that I had coworkers asking me during my lunch break what I was reading because I don’t usually spend my lunch so lovingly enraptured by my cell phone.

An extremely charming romance centered around two Black adults in their 50s who are thrown together during Christmas, The Royal Holiday is an easy book to jump into, even without having read other books in the series. All I had known was that the book was loosely inspired by a news story about Queen Elizabeth inviting the mother of Duchess Meghan to spend Christmas with the royals (which obviously launched a thousand squee ships of joy), and I didn’t feel lost at all inside the narrative despite not knowing the back stories of the other characters.

Me in love with just all of this book
Patrick from Spongebob Squarepants looking deeply enchanted with what is in front of him

My knowledge of Duchess Meghan and her mom is fairly limited, so it was pretty easy to forget the fact that this book is inspired by a real person. And this could just be my own ignorance speaking (as I have not been particularly interested in asking the internet about more specifics), but it seems like the similarities between reality and fiction stop at the point where both have a middle-aged Black woman from California with some connection to the British royal family. Ultimately, forgetting about reality and getting settled into the narrative was easy to do because the characters and the story were so engrossing.

Vivian Forest is the mother of a woman hired as the stylist to a Duchess for the Christmas holidays. Malcolm Hudson (initially nicknamed Hot Chocolate by Vivian!) is the private secretary to the Queen. They are at the same estate because the royal family is spending Christmas together and Malcolm, as part of his service to the Queen, must stay close because Parliament is causing trouble and he needs to keep her informed.

Vivian and Malcolm find each other very quickly at the beginning of Vivian’s trip and over a short number of days they are not hesitant to jump into a holiday romance. They are single adults in their 50s with very little situational or internal drama attached to their existence (no one is on the run, no meddling exes, no deep dark secrets, no struggle with some inexorable destiny prophesied long ago), so there is no shame and no denial over the attraction they feel towards each other. Like Vivian and Malcolm, this romance doesn’t shy away from the sexy bits. While there is on-the-page sex, the characters take a reasonable amount of time to get there in their relationship, so though the characters are immediately attracted to each other there are no real instalust issues in this story. It’s all very delightful and very low conflict. And generally hilarious.

Vivian’s got jokes:

No matter what, she’d [Vivian] better go downstairs showered, with her hair in place, and with a bra on. There might be a prince in the kitchen, for God’s sake.

And some unrepentant man-ogling:

Vivian couldn’t decide what appealed to her more, hot coffee and fresh scones, or that man in the corner who looked like a tall mug of hot chocolate.

Why choose?

Both? Both.

men agreeing that the best choice is best

But also, Malcolm and Vivian together are a hoot:

“There’s nothing to be terrified about,”[Malcolm] said. “The horses will be lovely to you, I promise, and so will the staff.”

Would she be open to getting on a horse? Would the stable master give her the chance? For some reason, he was very much hoping she’d be able to have this opportunity.

[Vivian] raised an eyebrow at him.

“Oh, you can speak for horses now?”

He nodded seriously.

“The Queen’s horses are monarchists; they would never dare to mistreat a guest of the royal family.”

They looked at each other and laughed.

The only major conflict is at the end of the time they have together. Since Vivian lives in Oakland, California, and Malcolm’s job serving the Queen obviously means he has to stick close to where she is, they decide that neither wants to do a long-distance relationship.

To which I’m like:

two men saying "Come on, son"

SPOILER ALERT
Obviously, they get over that nonsense.

There were two big things that I loved about this story. One moment was at the wooing and flirting stage where the main characters wrote notes to each other and, because they are on a royal estate, they had footmen delivering their cute little letters back and forth to each other. Malcolm knows that Vivian, who pokes gentle fun at the staid Englishness of many of the traditions she encounters, would find communication via footmen-delivered notes on official stationary to be hilarious and all he wants to do is delight her.

Both characters acknowledge that they are in a space that makes them more aware of their Blackness and, in particular, the former British empire’s own historical relationship to race and oppression. But, they also refuse to bound by that history. It was a fun surprise to see hints of this double consciousness. Upon meeting Malcolm, Vivian almost immediately asks him if he is the first Black man to serve the Queen as the private secretary and Vivian perpetually worries that the estate staff will resent having to serve someone like her, a Black (and American) woman in her 50s. They still manage to gleefully engage in a particular piece of a traditional English courtship, both aware of the anachronistic nature of their flirting, but also aware of how no part of their current circumstances would have been possible in the time period of that practice.

I love historical romance novels despite the fact that the story often fails to acknowledge that it is operating within a time period where various kinds of people were being exploited, often (but not exclusively) through slavery, and that many of the main characters are able to live very comfortable lives through their conscious and unconscious participation in very violent systems of oppression. And so, I sometimes engage in a fair bit of mental gymnastics where I tell myself that perhaps the book is set in the multiverse, in another universe where all the characters aren’t overwhelmingly White and did not get their wealth through the exploitation of labor and conquering of people of color. Which would then excuse the characters for never discussing slavery. It would totally makes sense for there to be no discussion of slavery in a universe that has no slavery! So in some ways, by engaging in this multiverse overlay of historical romances I’m doing the genre a kindness, meeting it where it is and reframing it in my own headcanon so that it is something more complex and reflective of a world I’m looking for, but it is extra work I do.

What Royal Holiday gave me was an opportunity to not have to bend over backwards. The story lets two Black people engage in silly historical romantic tropes and simultaneously acknowledge why their Blackness means they would have never been able to engage in such practices in the past while also refusing to have that be a reason to limit the choices they are making in the present.

The other thing I loved about these characters is that they are both Black people who are extraordinarily good at their jobs and who have to carry not only the hefty responsibilities of their actual positions, but also know that they represent the hopes and dreams–some denied, some deferred–of the people who came before them and those who follow in their footsteps. Both struggle with the psychological impacts of shouldering that responsibility alone and are only beginning to acknowledge that they have other choices besides choosing the greater good over creating a life for themselves that makes them happy.

But, this book does not dwell on the ways Vivian and Malcolm are unhappy; it only firmly roots the story in the realities of what it means to be a Black person and never lets those realities be a barrier to falling in love. In the end, this story is overwhelmingly about saying yes to good things put directly in your path. If all you want to do is wrap yourself up in a Christmas love story with two adults just admirably adulting all the way through the book, I say grab a Christmas sweater and a hot chocolate, and get ready to have a stranger ask you why you look so happy reading the book you have in your hand!

This book is available from:
  • Available at Amazon
  • Order this book from apple books

  • Order this book from Barnes & Noble
  • Order this book from Kobo
  • Order this book from Google Play

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
We also may use affiliate links in our posts, as well. Thanks!

Royal Holiday by Jasmine Guillory

View Book Info Page

Add Your Comment →

  1. Rhiannon says:

    I’m so glad to read a review of it – I added myself to the library hold list as soon as I saw the book had been pre-ordered.

  2. Lisa F says:

    This is a B+ for me – not quite up to the level of the rest of the series, but still a nice, fluffy holiday-centered escape.

  3. LauraL says:

    @ Maya – I really enjoyed your review of Royal Holiday and am glad the book made you smile so much! I have it on my holiday reading list. Now am really looking forward to drinking coffee out of a holiday mug and catching up with Vivian’s adventures. Vivian made an appearance in The Wedding Party and I recommend reading the rest of the books in the series.

  4. MaryK says:

    She’s the “queen of contemporary romance”? Ugh. 🙁

  5. Maya says:

    Thanks, @LauraL! The rest of the series is definitely in my TBR pile!!

  6. Kris Bock says:

    Off to see if my library has it, and if not, ask them to get it!

  7. Anon says:

    @MaryK – I’m guessing you’d call someone else the queen of contemps?

  8. Laura says:

    struggling with this author due to the PR surrounding her.

  9. MaryK says:

    @Anon – I’d probably nominate JAK. Certainly someone who’s been writing romance more than two or three years. Nobody gets the title just because they’ve been discovered by random people outside romance circles.

  10. Kate says:

    I love her books so much, and this one is no exception! It is very cute and charming.

    At the same time, there are some real problems with how her work is marketed as super groundbreaking, particularly for Black romance. None of what she is doing is new! It’s great, but not new. It makes me feel weird about enjoying her books because of this weird erasure of complex, well-written romance, not only about Black characters but also other things, like having clear consent and having characters with in-depth lives and jobs. I’ve seen all of that praised as something new she is doing, and no. So much of the praise of her work feels like a complisult to the romance genre.

  11. Tina says:

    This is a lovely review! I like her books fine enough. They aren’t anything groundbreaking. This one sounds super cute and I am gonna read it only because over 50 rep in romance is rare and for black protagonists it is rarer still.

    Regards her PR, I don’t follow it closely at all. I know she has gotten the attention of big names (Reese, Oprah) and because of it is able to penetrate PR spaces that have otherwise been largely denied romance.

    I read a recent article that was written about like what I assume non-romance reading writers would write where the writer is gushy and makes hyperbolic statements that people who are longtime readers of romance would roll their eyes. But she herself seems rather benign, tho.

  12. This sounds completely delightful, and is going straight into my Kobo.

Add Your Comment

Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

*


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

↑ Back to Top