Other Media Review

Movie Review: Lion

Once upon a time, a little boy fell asleep on a train and woke up thousands of miles from home.

This is the story of Saroo Brierley, an Australian who, when he was a five year old in India, got separated from his family and after many twists and turns was adopted by a family in Australia. Once he grew up, he used Google Earth to find out where he was from. It’s a heart-tugging story that doesn’t entirely shy away from the difficulties of trans-culture adoption, explores the question of “what is home?” and manages the difficult task of “how do you make someone using Google Earth interesting to watch?”

The story begins in 1987 in Northern India, when five year old Saroo (played by the utterly charming Sunny Pawar) and his brother head off to find some work to help their mother and younger sister. Saroo proves to be too young, and is told by his brother to wait at the train station, and when his brother doesn’t come back, he crawls into an empty train and falls asleep. The train takes off while he’s still sleeping, and days pass before it stops and he can get off – in Calcutta, well over a thousand miles away, where people speak Bengali, and Saroo only speaks Hindi.

Eventually he ends up in an orphanage, and after no one can figure out where he’s from or who he belongs to, he’s adopted by a couple in Australia. Later on, the couple adopts another boy from India, Mantosh. Twenty years later, he meets an American student, Lucy, (Rooney Mara) and a few other Indian students. He remembers bits of his life before Australia, and uses Google Earth to trace where his journey had taken him, eventually returning to home and his mother.

This movie is beautiful. Dev Patel is utterly fantastic as the adult Saroo (and by the way, he was also “cute” and “adorable” and now he’s SMOKING HOT. It’s not quite a Neville Longbottoming, but it’s in the category).

He goes through a lot of emotions while he searches: he doesn’t want to seem ungrateful to his parents (Nicole Kidman and David Wenham) but he also feels awful that his mother never knew what happened to him. It’s a case where he doesn’t quite feel like he has permission to feel all his feelings, especially when it seemed clear to me that tiny Saroo made a choice to accept the Brierleys as his family.

Dev Patel in a grey suit with dark grey double breasted waistcoat and grey tie looking disheveled and handsome
This is NOT FAIR.

Mantosh doesn’t make the adjustment well. It is abundantly clear that being adopted offers a much better life than staying in the orphanage, but neither he nor Saroo are “blank pages” and come with a lot of trauma. A woman I worked with several years ago adopted a five year old boy from India, and it was still a work in progress when I left that job.  While there really isn’t any discussion about the two boys losing their culture (the Breirleys keep the boys’ names, which I think is important), it’s clear that this wasn’t just a simple “here you go, here’s your room and a television, everything is great!” transition. Even Saroo didn’t prepare them for the challenges Mantosh presented, just like any subsequent child.

Tiny Saroo’s adventures in Calcutta are upsetting. I would not recommend this movie for Sarah, or anyone else who does not handle “children in peril” well. He’s always ultimately safe, but it’s due to luck and his own good instincts, not because bad things weren’t possible. And bad things do happen to other children. He’s lost, and alone, and can’t speak the language, and when he does find adults who want to help him, they don’t recognize the name of his village, and he doesn’t know his mother’s name (“What’s your mother’s name?” “Mum.”). It’s upsetting.

We’ve seen in modern movies how difficult it can be to make computers dramatic. Spotlight did a pretty good job of it, and as Saroo is searching through the Google Earth images, it’s cut with flashes of the memory of a five year old – a scared, hungry, lonely five year old. It works pretty well.

Dev and Sunny at the Golden Globes. Awards season has given us MANY of these moments, and this kiddo has been slaying everyone anywhere he goes.

This is based on the book by the actual Saroo, A Long Way Home ( A | BN | K | AB ), which I have not read (yet). It’s been nominated for Best Picture, Best Supporting Actor for Dev Patel, Best Supporting Actress for Nicole Kidman, Best Adapted Screenplay, Best Cinematography, and Best Score.

It’s easily one of the best movies I’ve seen this year, and, if you can handle the parts with children in peril, I highly recommend it.

Lion is in theaters now and tickets (US) are available at Fandango and Moviefone.

Add Your Comment →

  1. I’ll go a long, long way to avoid a ‘heart-tugging story’ but this one was on the BAFTA voting shortlist, so I had to at least give it a go. I thought I’d maybe last ten minutes but it pulled me right in. Engrossing, suspenseful and beautifully made.

  2. cayenne says:

    I’m not big on overtly emotionally manipulative movies, but I didn’t get that feeling from this film, even though it ticks all the boxes that should make it one. I saw it at TIFF last fall, liked it for all the reasons RHG mentioned, and came away thinking “well, there’s the People’s Choice Award winner”, an award which often seems to lead to the Best Picture Oscar. And then La La Land took over the festival and much of this year’s award season, and this lovely movie got lost in the crowd. I’d particularly call out the performance of Sunny Pawar, who was excellent.

  3. Kay Sisk says:

    My husband and I saw this and neither of us could recommend it enough to our friends. Seeing footage of the real Saroo reuniting with his family is worth the price of the ticket.

  4. Crystal says:

    If anybody needs me, I’m one-clicking that book.

  5. Crystal says:

    Also, THAT GIF. I know it’s shallow, and it’s not like I haven’t seen it before. But it kills me. SO CUTE.

  6. lolagranola says:

    Literally cried the entire time I saw this, in the theater. Just incredible.

  7. Margaret says:

    I DID read the book, and it was quite good. There was no American student in it, so I’m hoping that extra wasn’t given too much time or energy in the film. The book did a great job of conveying his love and commitment to BOTH of his mothers and his extreme gratitude for the good fortune that allowed him to get to the point where he could tell his tale when there were so many opportunities for misfortune along the way. It’s definitely the kind of book that leaves you feeling very guilty for complaining about a “bad day,” but one that also makes you believe that miracles are, indeed, possible.

  8. mel burns says:

    I really want to see Lion. First off it has Dev Patel and second it has Dev Patel. I have adored him since Slumdog Millionaire and his performance in Newsroom was terrific. Thanks for the review.

  9. KellyM says:

    Excellent review!
    Now I want to see this movie, but since I don’t do movies alone(I am gutless), don’t know a living sole where I live now, and my husband will only go to sci-fi movies, I will have to wait until it come to disc. Sigh.

  10. Hazel says:

    I usually detest anything ‘heartwarming’, but this was surprisingly good. The youngsters in the Indian scenes were excellent; convincing and moving. And Dev is maturing nicely.

  11. Rehana says:

    Saw it yesterday, LOVED IT!! but couldn’t stop crying.

Add Your Comment

Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

*


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

↑ Back to Top