B-
Genre: Erotica/Erotic Romance, Romance, Science Fiction/Fantasy
Theme: Fated Mates, Forced Proximity (stranded, safehouse, etc)
Archetype: Alien/Monster
If you ever just need to turn your brain off for a sec, might I suggest Toxic Desire by Robin Lovett. It’s an erotic science fiction romance where two enemies are stranded on a sex planet. There are some pacing issues and the pages given to all of the sex scenes may have been better utilized, but it’s so over the top and campy that you just have to settle in for the ride.
Before we go any further, I want to make it abundantly clear this is an erotic romance. There is sex and lots of it. If you were unsure of the level of sexual content, let me assuage your worries and reiterate for the people in the back: THERE IS LOTS OF IT.
Nemona or “Nem” is a deserter of the Ten Systems. The Systems are known for their tyrannical rule and violent quest for power. Nem was part of their military but after realizing this wasn’t the kind of government she wanted to support, she gathered a crew of Ten Systems citizens who felt the same way and went rogue. Now they use their Ten Systems ship to conduct research missions, wanting to know more about the universe and people in it.
Oten is a Ssedez, a member of a god-like warrior race with impenetrable armored skin. They’re very snake-like in appearance with forked tongues and fangs. There is no love lost between the Ssedez and the Ten Systems, as Oten’s race was forced into faking their own genocide to go into hiding after the Systems sought to eradicate them. Seeing a Ten Systems ship near their new hidden home forces Oten and his warriors to attack the ship.
Things definitely don’t go as planned as the ship and its escape shuttles crash on the planet Fyrian. The planet was given that name by outsiders because it’s been rumored that planet is literally on fire. But Oten and Nem soon realize it’s a “fire of the loins.” The atmosphere makes them experience physical and insatiable lust.
To complicate things further than being trapped on a sex planet with your enemy, the Ssdez have a mating ritual known as the Attachment. It’s sort of kind a “mate for life” scenario, though several steps have to be completed for the Attachment to take. Several things happen to Oten that signify he’s found his mate and being mated is something that he’s always longed for. However, Nem is human. Even if she did reciprocate, Oten isn’t sure how his fellow Ssedez will handle the news.
Oten’s backstory and his conflict about finding a lifelong partner is more heavily addressed. He’s adorable and confused and just wants to be loved. With Nem, her emotional baggage doesn’t make much of an appearance until the end and is a bit out of left field. But she is a stern badass. She’s also infertile, a procedure that was required as part of her military service.
I’m honestly torn about that detail because it was revealed once during a rather emotional and pivotal scene, only never to be talked about again. On one hand, Nem doesn’t seem to regret the decision, but I’m not an advocate of any forced sterilization, given how it’s been used throughout history. It also felt that though Nem was presented with a choice, saying no wasn’t really an option.
Toxic Desire is clearly divided into two parts. Part one is Nem and Oten’s “road trip” in the wilds of Fyrian. They’re trying to get to her crashed ship to see if there are any survivors and if her research has been destroyed. Part two is the reunion with her crew and the meeting of native Fyrians. The second half, for me, is where the good stuff happens and the sex is balanced out by introductions to new characters, a better understanding of the planet, and how Oten and Nem will address their relationship.
Not that the beginning half was bad, but all the sex scenes began to blur together without anything new being revealed. Oten has sex venom, fangs, a forked tongue, his ejaculate is silver, and that his Achilles’ heel is located in his penis.
Feel free to read that last sentence several times.
Not only is that a lot of detail, but it’s all unloaded in one go. Much like Oten himself, lololololol.
The biology of the Ssedez is revealed rather quickly, which meant a good portion of the sex scenes were there for the hell of it. The scenes weren’t “furthering” anything for me in terms of plot or character development. I eventually reached a point where I did some skimming. I have no issues with erotic romance, but I would have preferred a more evenly threaded balance between sex, world building, action, and character development. It was a little lopsided.
Now let’s talk consent.
Consent can only be freely given when all parties and clear-headed and unimpaired. With the atmosphere of the planet heightening the characters’ arousal to painful levels, they were compelled to have sex to offer temporary release. Nem and Oten are almost frenzied to ease their sexual pain. But were they in their right mind? Were they in possession of all their faculties?
I would say no. However, there are moments when Nem makes it clear that she doesn’t want to have sex with Oten and he keeps his distance. They’ll have to achieve release on their own and they do.
The issue of consent left me conflicted, though I ultimately came to the conclusion that Oten and Nem respected each other’s boundaries when communicated. Other readers may have a different interpretation, so I’d rather everyone be forewarned before picking this up.
There is also a discussion of gender identity that I want to warn readers about as well. Nem makes a decision as captain that her crew should keep their genders hidden. This happens at the beginning of the book, and toward the climax of the story (literal climax, not sexual climax – there’s more than one of those). The directive to conceal gender is s a leftover tenet they’ve retained from when they served the Ten Systems. Nem believes wearing androgynous suits will help curb any conflict or bias, and will keep her crew safer. Her crew highly disagrees with this decision, wishing to express their gender identities freely. When Nem is reunited with the survivors of the Ssedez attack, she’s surprised to see they’ve adopted a democratic process and have reversed some of her mandates she made, namely keeping gender identities a secret.
Rather than re-establishing her position as captain, Nem respects the decisions her crew has made, though seems slightly unsettled. She’s lived her life being ambiguous in terms of her own gender, and she has some anxiety that she’ll be judged or viewed differently by her crew, or those that think women shouldn’t serve in positions of power
It was an interesting concept that I wish were explored more, though I found it oddly coincidental that her surviving crew members were all women or identified as such. I would have traded some of the sex scenes for several insightful discussions between Nem and her crew, mainly because I found this to be more fascinating than all the creative ways Nem and Oten made use of their parts.
However, I never felt that Nem truly accepted this decision on a deeper, personal level or substantially wrestled with how this affected her own negative feelings about being a woman in a position of power, or her thoughts on finally being able to see her crew. She never reflected on her initial call to force her crew to hide their gender identities.
I don’t want it to seem like I didn’t enjoy this book because I did. It’s a bonkers fun read and sometimes, that’s what I need. My main issue was the pacing and how certain aspects of the plot were distributed. And while some fascinating aspects were introduced in regards to the different alien races and Nem’s crew, they fell just shy of giving me what I wanted, which was a deeper examination of all characters involved. There are also several things I mentioned (gender identity, sterilization, and consent) that could be particularly sensitive issues for readers.
The books in the series appear to be connected; I’m assuming I’ll get more info for my nosy brain when I continue. Yes, it’s a “when” not an “if.” Mostly, I’m just curious what sorts of things Lovett will write next because her imagination seems limitless.
Look, it’s a romance set on a sex planet. It does what it says on the tin. Besides, aren’t you the slightest bit curious?
This book is available from:
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
We also may use affiliate links in our posts, as well.
Thanks!
Another one for the erotic alien romance bingo /drinking game I reckon!
Yeah—those Planet of Desire books (I think Lovett has published three so far) are bonkers. Sarah McLean said they are “a full five bananas on the banana scale.” But I must admit, even with all the problematic elements you rightly point out, I do enjoy them. In a way, they remind me of the soft-core porn novels we’d surreptitiously pass around in junior high (hey, give me a break, it was the seventies!): lots of sex intermingled with scenes that carried the plot and world-building. For me, the Planet of Desire books are (somewhat nostalgic) guilty pleasures.
I just set this book aside because all the sex seemed so much the same, but I never got to the second part…maybe I should give it a whirl…?
@Vivi12: I did some skimming with all the sex scenes, but the second half definitely has a drop off on erotic material. It also introduces the rest of the cast so more happens.
This sounds like something I would like, but I read the sample and it is first person. Crud, I hate first person. Pass.
I also read this book recently and completely agree with this review. (I heard about it via Joanna Shupe on Twitter: “You guys, RUN to start reading this series!!”) It’s a good in between book for fun. But I agree it could have been paced better. Still I also will probably read another in the series when the timing is right. It did feel like the author front loaded the sex to draw in readers but of course I was more interested in the back stories and world building. Also, the book was very funny, a plus for me.
also.
can we talk about his magic ejaculate.
because…it’s bonkers. and i am here for it.
*ROFL*
This seems so iddy and fanficcy and tropey and I am DYING.
“If you ever just need to turn your brain off for a sec” — say no more. Click!
I love this whole series! Deliciously bananas, inventive, and super hot.
Ok Amanda, I love your reviews. I have said in other forums that if Amanda on SBTB likes it, I usually end up liking it too.
This line exhibits why:
“Not only is that a lot of detail, but it’s all unloaded in one go. Much like Oten himself, lololololol.”
Normally, this line would have me going to get this book. Because it’s hilarious and my brand of gross humor. However, as I read on, I realized I have actually ALREADY read this book and had a similar reaction. I thought that it was good, amusing, with issues of consent, and I wished there was more to the gender conflict.
This book is ridiculous. But if you enjoy erotica and scifi and laughing at yourself, it’s a winner.
May I make a suggestion for SBTB? When reviewing Erotica it might be helpful to list (even if under a spoiler tag) the types (not sure that is the right word but I am going to go with it) of sex in the book. For example ménage is an absolute no go for me, but I am sure for others it might be certain role playing, BDSM, certain toys/props, etc. I think most if not all of the readers of the site are fairly fluent in the various heat levels (and what to expect from those levels) of non-Erotica romance, but Erotica seems to a variety of different avenues that may or may not be welcomed by a reader. Just a thought – maybe I am in the only one who find this helpful!
Thank you very much for this review – this is very much Not My Genre (the sexy aliens, not the erotica necessarily) but I think I’m going to give it a shot nonetheless.
I also wanted to let you know that I was a bit unsettled by the reference to the crew ‘all [being] women or identif[ying] as such’. It strikes me as genuine attempt to be inclusive and accurate, but it’s my understanding that drawing that kind of parallel, even accidentally, sets up cis women as ‘women’ while trans women only ‘IDENTIFY as women’ and can be really othering and invalidating. Just ‘women’ should cover it fine, unless there are feminine-identifying nonbinary people in the crew, in which case you could try something like ‘non-men’ or ‘that none of her surviving crew members were men’, or just spelling it out entirely. (I did try to Google around a bit for a term that could be used, but English is still awkward for things like this, and I didn’t want to suggest something like ‘all female aligned’ without being really sure it was appropriate, since I’m not nonbinary or trans.)
I want to be clear that SBTB has always been, to my knowledge, really good around these types of things, and I’m not trying to call anybody out; it just seemed likely to me that you would want to know, and important to mention it.