“I’m Your Man” (2020) is a charming philosophical rom-com directed by Maria Schrader and starring Dan Stevens, Maren Eggert, and Sandra Hüller, currently available on Netflix and Kanopy in the US. It’s entirely in German with English subtitles (yes, the British Stevens speaks fluent German throughout) so be forewarned if you hate subtitles.
The premise is this: A 40-something single archeologist agrees to live for three weeks with a humanoid robot who’s been programmed to fulfill her every desire. At the end of the experiment, she will provide an evaluation and receive money to fund her current study. This may sound similar to other sci-fi films like “ex Machina,” “Her,” or even “The Stepford Wives,” but its lightly comedic script and performances make it considerably more delightful (and thoughtful) than those films.
Stevens’ android Tom is a naïve people-pleaser, and bewildered that Alma, his human, has no interest in the ways he tries to delight her. In fact, she’s annoyed at the very idea of the experiment. Having just broken up with a human man, she doesn’t want a robot (even a very appealing one) cooking her breakfast, cleaning her apartment, and drawing her bubble baths. It’s great fun to watch Tom cock his head in concentration as he tries to adjust his algorithm to Alma’s confusing directions to be more human.
Stevens’ acting is superb. He is quoted as saying he studied Cary Grant’s performance in Bringing Up Baby(!) to prepare for the role. Tom is quite human looking, sounding and acting, save for his slightly stiff movements. He is far smarter and more competent than any human male could ever be. He is attentive. He listens. He understands. This drives Alma up the wall.
Alma is prickly. She’s messy, her hair straggly, her coat billowing around her. They are a classic screwball comedy pair of opposites. But Tom’s lack of humanity sends Alma into despair as she exclaims, “I’m acting, but there’s no audience! I’m only talking to myself!”
This is a warm and very compassionate film written and directed by women that is firmly based in the woman’s point of view. Does Alma need a man, or a “man,” to be happy? Is happiness the purpose of life? (Tom thinks it is.)
Alma’s decision to send Tom back to the factory to be erased makes us, the audience, hold our breaths. We’ve come to love Tom, too. There’s more film to come, though, and the ending is likely to keep you thinking for a long time.
“I’m Your Man” may cement notions you have about AI destroying the world by addicting humans to cushy comfort, or it may bring you hope about curing the world’s apparent loneliness epidemic. Or, like me, you may wonder about the ethics of creating creatures to serve us. The film raises many questions and offers no easy answers, just like love … but it does take us on a captivating ride.
This Guest Review is from Patricia Milton! Patricia is an award-winning playwright and novelist who lives in the San Francisco Bay Area.