After reading a scene in which the heroine was a surprise virgin (Surprise! Virgin!) I tweeted about how tired I was of the Surprise Virgin afterglow conversations.
Picture it. The hero figures out the heroine is a virgin because he encounters some resistance (which, don’t even get me started) and she flinches and of course he Is Very Alarmed and tries to stop but she tells him not to so it’s ok for him to get on with it.
Then after they’ve crested and reached peaks of joy and done the dance as old as time, he says something about how if he’d known she was a virgin, he’d have done it all differently, been more gentle or something.
First, why would you not bring your A game the first time you sleep with a woman you have major lust pants for? If you groin is on fire and it’s not because of Gold Bond, why would you not do your very best scrumpin? What is this “I’d have been more gentle and sensitive” crap?
Second, he knew she was a virgin as soon as he encountered her gasp upon his plunge (and can we stop with the “to the hilt” nonsense? I get it, he could… go… all… the … way. But enough with the hilt). He had plenty of time to gentle it up but no, he was overcome with lust, and pounded away like a poundy thing, and it’s her fault for not telling him she was a virgin before he plunged his hilt.
So I vented about it on Twitter, and this began a very rapid discussion, which I believe sets up a list of requests for future virgin sex scene cliche avoiding.
First, the OMG U WERE VIRGIN DAMN MY HARDON scenes have to go. Enough with the ‘You were a virgin? I’d have done it differently….” Why? This is why:

And then there was this response:
Yes. Yes it should
The ubiquity of this type of scene begs a few more questions. For one thing, what WOULD he have done differently? Brought flowers and some wine to her hymen?
And how does he know? Sometimes he feels it. COME ON.
Do we need to go over the location of the hymen again?
Another question:
What does the differently mean? Seriously. Why would virgins want something that was more of a performance than a genuine physical expression? It’s not like virgins get interpretive dance sex… do they!?
Another question:
Yes. That too. How is it that sex is something HE does until she begs for it and then it’s ok to pop her cherry in retrospect? ARGH. How is it that both people are consenting adults but he’s the one what’s “doing” things, and would therefore “do” them differently?
Are virgins never on top?
Then there’s the reverse:
I don’t think that’s ok, either, but at least some difference is progress, right?
There are other scenes we are tired of, too. Kate Johnson brought up another corollary to the OMG U WERE VIRGIN? cliche scene:
YES. How is it that there are all these virginal heroines running around and everyone knows, remarks on said virgin status, and it’s common knowledge among so many? WTF?
Even if I did know about someone being a virgin I can’t think of any circumstance in which I’d bring it up. It’s not like it’s first-thing-in-the-elevator conversation each morning: “So, how’s your hymen today? Still there?”
And speaking of virgins, they have their own collection of cliche scenes, including this one:
Yeah, I’m over that cliche, too. Enough of the virgin Havisham who is going to dine on the memory of her deflowering until she’s old, dusty and decrepit. For never shall she meet another wang interested in her moldy wedding cake.
So, to sum up, Virginity Cliches are tiresome. I’d be happy to not read any of these again.
Oh – and this one, too:
YES.
Remember, people. Chaste is only two letters away from “chafe.”











Jeez. I’m so sorry that happened to you. What a douchemonkey.
May your next experience be fabulous. :/
In a related weirdness, why is it in film when a couple engages in some standing up foreplay, the woman always gets pushed against a wall? Even in nasty car garages when she’s wearing her fancy duds? It jumped out at me in this last Once Upon a Time when the evil sorceress, already established as a sexual predator, gets pushed into a wall by her male sexual victim.
And there’s the reason I will never touch another Lisa Valdez book. Amazing that she can come up with interesting characters and conflicts but write the absolute WORST sex ever.
Could we put @so and so so we will know who you are replying to?
There’s nothing to be ashamed of. I threw my virginity away on the first guy who paid attention to me because my peers kept telling me I was so fat and ugly I’d die a virgin and I wanted to prove them wrong. Asshole then turned around and started to abuse me. Told me all the time that I was stupid for believing in God, that I was an idiot for liking Star Trek better than Star Wars, then the abuse got physical and I got out of there.
And even my sexual experiences after that – eh. Nothing to write home about. Tried BDSM, found it boring. I’ve never had an orgasm. It’s always just been boring, painful, and frankly just not worth the time or energy. Maybe if I find a man I actually love it would be better. But as of now I honestly do not miss it. What I miss is having someone to go to the movies with, to talk about things, who’ll put his arm around my shoulders or hold my hand.
So NEVER be ashamed to be a virgin. I’m not kidding when I say I wish I still was. It was a horrible mistake to have sex, especially for the reasons I did. And I can happily live without it.
There’s nothing wrong with saving yourself for someone you actually care about. Even if they don’t end up your One True Love, at least you can say you lost it to someone you wanted to be with. Not someone who was convenient!
And if anyone ever does try to make you feel ashamed for waiting, tell them I said they were morons and to shut their yaps.
Actually, Virginia, if you look next to the “such & such minutes ago” if it’s a reply to someone else it’ll say “In reply to” next to it. Well, if they clicked the reply button that is.
I wish there was a way to tell which of my posts people liked without having to enter every single thread I’ve replied in though. LOL
omg how have I not followed you guys before???
Aaaaauuughghghhgh the virgin issue(s) is so annoying!! But real-life 30-year-old virgins also freak me out (yes I know several) so there ya go…
I just finished “The Outlander” by Diana Gabaldon. Not sure it falls completely in the romance novel category, but it has some steamy scenes and lots of drama. The book does a flip though. She’s a woman with some experience from the 1940s and he’s a 23 year old virgin from the Highlands near the time of Culloden. Really enjoyed the story.
Hey! I just realized the new format has a ‘click here for more comments’ button. I’d been wondering why I wasn’t getting many comments to read! I still think the HP virgin garbage king from a few weeks back wins the virgins in romance competition!
Mind if I ask why, Sophia? Is it just that the ones you know are kind of creepy about it? Because I will admit that women, and men, who sleep with a lot of people creep me out. I keep thinking of things like herpes and HIV and all that when they talk about hooking up with random people.
I honestly think with all we know now adays it makes more sense to stay a virgin until in a committed relationship and just don’t see why they’d be creepy. Unless they were some Hollywood stereotype of a virgin.
Like Jami, I’d be curious as to why. I mean, if we’re talking the Steve Carrell stereotype, then I’d be freaked out, too. But most of the 30-year-old virgins I know (and i know quite a few) are normal people pursuing normal lives.
I have to say – when I lost my virginity, it didn’t hurt, we did have sex three times, and I wasn’t really that sore after that I recall. Then again, we’d had, like, months of some super-intense everything-but.
After following this thread I read an article about Tim Tebow (American football star) – who is a virgin and is saving himself for marriage. So there’s one publicly known virgin. And I thought – now there’s a good romance set up.
Back in my teens and early twenties, when I was a virgin, I did know the status of most of my close friends’ virginity or lack thereof. One of the lovely things about getting older, at least for me, is that I no longer know much, if anything, about my friends’ sex life.
I had wang meets cervix happen in my book: She had been knocked on the cervix once and had seen stars. Not the good kind.
Of course no one read Perfectly Wicked.
Lynsay Sands had a short story about a female vampire published recently where the hero was in his 60s. In her series the vampires look 20-30, even if they are changed once they are older. I love her Argeneau series, but I felt like this particular book was a good start that was never developed.
I have to say, it’s SO comforting reading this thread. I’ve been feeling like a freak ever since hitting thirty with the only person who’s ever been near my bits being my doctor. Not religious (well, I am, but I figure God gave me this equipment to enjoy), not frigid, just not real lucky with relationships. Haven’t found the goofy geek of my dreams yet.
I’ve thought about just finding a wang and getting it over with, but that makes me feel all icky. In the immortal words of Cher Horowitz, “You see how picky I am about my shoes, and they only go on my feet.” Why can’t that be enough of a reason, in contemporary romance and in real life?
Glad I’m not the only over-30 here. I had a really great discussion with my doctor about this whole issue just this week, so it was on my mind even before I came in (late) to the thread.
I gotta ask…are you the same mosylu who wrote HP fic back in the day? B/c you were one of my favorites. :/
Ha! My best friend was VERY concerned when she received an e-mail with the subject line: ‘SURPRISE HYMEN!’
XD
Yep, guilty. Still writing, just not HP anymore. Glad you enjoyed it!
actually, I’ve read quite a few of the “she woke up with a soreness in muscles she didnt know she had” I usually figure those are inner thighs
that. is . disgusting. and horrifying. and you fail biology forever miss author
“So, how’s your hymen today?”
Home alone.
Does anyone feel like we should have a discussion now about heroines who are sexually active before the hero? I’d sure like to know if anyone besides me finds it creepy when the heroine sleeps with a guy she just barely knows, if at all, in contemporaries. Historicals I can deal with it, but in contemporaries all I can think about is “Girl, haven’t you heard of things like herpes and HIV?!” I just finished one called Golden Threads by Kay Hooper where the heroine slept with the hero after two dates, decided she was in love with him, and both were TSTL – and he was a FBI agent with a law degree!
Oh my goodness I had no idea this was such a hot-button – I shouldn’t have spoken!
But yes, the few I know are not just anti-sex, they’re anti-relationship in general. I can’t talk about dating or human connections with them in general, and it’s sad when people are so cut off from their bodies or relating to others in an intimate/emotional way. But I went to grad school for Marriage, Family Therapy counseling so I’m biased towards relationship lol.
My first time, I pretty much literally decided I was going to do “it”, headed out to find a willing male to do “it”, was pretty sure he would dump me immediately because we hadn’t even had a first date before we did “it”, “it” was dreadful, and even more horribly, HE WOULDN’T GO AWAY.
I mean, I make no pretence about loving the guy – I didn’t. He just. wouldn’t. leave. me. alone. He suddenly was all hearts and flowers and let’s get married, and I … just wanted him to go away. It took the better part of a semester to get him to do so.
Worth saying, making love is vastly better than doing “it”.
Hubby says: ’ “to the hilt”, is probably a little more tactful than “balls deep”. XD
What’s with the “pounding” anyway? I can’t seem to stop myself from picturing a meat mallet. Is he making escalopes? Can I have some?
I dunno.
At 26, I think I’d have my heroine tell the lucky lad she’s a virgin, but has much practice with self pleasure and a vibrating jack rabbit. Think that would fly? 😉
I know ya’ll have said in your book how the losing the virginity thing isn’t scream worthy traumatic stuff, but let me just say…mine was. It hurt like hell, and I bled for two days. The damn thing was the consistency of a tupperwear lid. Now I’m sure that muscle tension because of the pain didn’t help the situation, but still…I hollered a bit.
Really enjoyed this post and all the comments. I agree completely with you on this! It is such a common and overused phenomenon in romance novels. So cliched!