I really struggled with how to grade this book, mostly because I appreciated what it was trying to do even if I think it did not succeed. I mean, a lot of the ingredients are there: a teenage babysitter’s club that’s actually a coven of witches is a bomb-ass premise, the secondary characters were intriguing, and there were some genuinely funny jokes. So what’s the problem? The primary issue, craft-wise, was that this was a … Continue reading The Babysitters Coven by Kate Williams →