Book Review

Bluebird by Ciel Pierlot

Bluebird is science fiction that includes the following: a female protagonist, two love stories of which one is f/f and one f/m, a spaceship, smuggling, a bar fight, political intrigue, badass librarians, secret identities, found and biological family, rebellion, a heist, major angst, chase scenes, and jewelry. I could not one-click this thing fast enough, and presumably most of you will not actually read this review because you have also one-clicked and are already reading the book.

For the, I don’t know, maybe two of you that remain, here’s the basic plot. A hefty chunk of the universe is ruled by three factions: Pyrite, Ascetic, and Ossuary. These factions have, among other things, colonized the homelands of the Kashrini people. Rig, a Kashrini, was recruited by Pyrite to help them develop weapons, which she did so very well that now she is on the run, refusing to give the plans for the weapon to any of the factions. Rig is currently a smuggler who rescues refugees and who steals Kashrini art and other valuables from the colonizers who stole it in the first place.

Rig gets into trouble when the Pyrite faction holds Rig’s twin sister, Daara, hostage until Rig returns the plans for the weapon. Luckily Rig finds herself with an unexpected passenger, Ginka, who has an almost supernatural skill at fighting. As the book progresses, we learn more about Rig, not to mention Ginka, whose mysterious back story is detailed and traumatic (there is no sexual assault, thank goodness). We also learn about Rig and Ginka’s respective romances.

This was a fun, exciting book with non-stop action and a powerful anti-imperialist, anti-colonialist message. The action takes many forms – there’s a heist, a motorbike chase, spaceships chasing each other, the above-mentioned bar fight – so if you like action, you’ll like the book, which has the kinetic appeal of the Indiana Jones movies but with a revolutionary heart. Picture the main characters chasing Indiana Jones down, reclaiming the treasure he stole, kicking his ass, and absconding with his hat, and you’ll get the picture. Meanwhile there’s heavier content in Rig’s desperation to save her sister and in Ginka’s backstory, adding some emotional weight and higher stakes to events.

My main problem with the book was that all the things that made me care about the characters were kept secret until late in the story. I get the concept of a mysterious backstory, but Ginka’s backstory was revealed in such tiny increments that she was a pretty blank slate most of the time. She was so good at concealing her personality that she basically didn’t have any until the book was almost over.

Because the characters lack depth for most of the story, it’s basically a big MacGuffin chase. Alfred Hitchock described the MacGuffin as “The thing that the characters on screen worry about, but the audience don’t care…in crook stories it is almost always the necklace, and in spy stories it is almost always the papers.”

The Mandalorian series is an example of an exceptionally well done story that uses a MacGuffin. Because the MacGuffin is Grogu, who is fucking adorable, and because the series spends time building the character of the Mandalorian and allowing him an endearing character arc, we care passionately not only about the people who want the MacGuffin (the Mandalorian, who spends all of his time either trying to find it or trying to protect it) and the MacGuffin itself. So, the set pieces are fun and exciting, but also emotional.

In Bluebird, we have a lot of action and conversations around finding stuff. Rig wants to find Daara, Pyrite wants to find the schematics, Ginka’s previous bosses want Ginka, etc. Sometimes an extra MacGuffin gets thrown in and then discarded, as when, in mid-heist, Rig decides to steal a Kashrini necklace in addition to accomplishing the mission she is actually there for and finally changes her mind. The story is written well enough to be fun in a ‘B-movie’ kind of a way, but that crucial element of passionate emotional investment in the characters and their motivations was missing for me.

The love stories have the same problem – two great love stories but doled out in teensy bits and pieces. If more of the details of the emotional connections had been revealed earlier, I would have been so much more interested and invested in the characters and the action. Without caring about the characters, the action felt empty, and a lot of those high stakes weren’t apparent right away.

One of the more interesting aspects to the book is how it deals with trauma and oppression. All of the characters are living under totalitarian governments, with varying levels of privilege. There’s a lot of discussion about who has privilege and why, and whether they will fight to keep it or choose another option.

There are also a lot of questions about identity – who gives you a name, what that means, and what it means to choose a name for yourself. All of the characters address these choices in different but plausible ways. For example, I liked that wearing a headscarf is a tradition of the Kashrini people, drawing from more diverse Earth/human cultural sources than Western ones. Cultural identity is also a big part of the book, especially for Rig. These are questions that are terribly relevant today and they provide a lot of gravitas that help anchor all those chase scenes.

Overall, I did enjoy the characters, the love stories, the action, the humor (Rig does excellent snark) and the anti-colonialism. However, I had a hard time keeping my focus on it and kept drifting off to other things. If I had known some key things about the characters earlier in the book, it would have been amazing. Instead, it’s pretty OK. Considering that this is a science fiction action story in which almost all of the characters are women, I’m guessing “pretty OK” will do it for most readers who, like me, enjoy anti-colonialist, feminist science fiction.

This book is available from:
  • Available at Amazon
  • Order this book from apple books

  • Order this book from Barnes & Noble
  • Order this book from Kobo

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
We also may use affiliate links in our posts, as well. Thanks!

Bluebird by Ciel Pierlot

View Book Info Page

Add Your Comment →

  1. JoanneBB says:

    Great review! I’m going to see if my library has it, instead of one clicking… I need characters I care about more than adventure.

  2. Mrs. Obed Marsh says:

    The bloggers at spec fic writing site Mythcreants call the withholding of information that motivates the viewpoint characters until it’s time for a big narrative turning point “meta mysteries” and they’re not fans. I’m inclined to agree. I understand why people include meta mysteries in their writing: they want to emulate the shocking twists they see, especially in film. But there’s two problems with that:

    1) A lot of writers are trying to imitate films, where we can only guess at a character’s private thoughts based on dialogue, facial expressions, musical cues, etc. Meta mysteries are a lot harder to pull off in written media, where we read every thought that passes through a viewpoint character’s head and only notice the things they notice. Often the viewpoint character has to pointedly avoid thinking about the stuff the author doesn’t want us to know yet, which stretches plausibility. We all know how well deciding not to think about something usually goes. (Don’t think about pink elephants!)

    2) I don’t know about you, but I can’t get invested in the stakes of a story if I have no idea what they are. It’s fine if the stakes change because the characters have uncovered new information, but it’s very much not fine if they’re doing their thing and I don’t know why I should care.

    No, the way to hide information in a character’s backstory is by not having them know it in the first place. Maybe the character’s guardians kept important details from them in order to control them, or because they thought the information would be too upsetting. Maybe the character has amnesia and can’t remember something they used to know. Maybe both! Then when the information finally comes out, the character gets to be shocked along with the audience. There’s your amazing twist, folks!

  3. EC Spurlock says:

    Picture the main characters chasing Indiana Jones down, reclaiming the treasure he stole, kicking his ass, and absconding with his hat, and you’ll get the picture.

    Sold in one sentence.

Add Your Comment

Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

*


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

$commenter: string(0) ""

↑ Back to Top