Book Review

The Alice Network by Kate Quinn

This is also part of my, “Okay, universe, just tell me what to read” campaign. This book has a lot of my catnip: lady spies, a dual chronology, and a host of people trying to put their lives back together after a war.

In 1947, Charlotte “Charlie” St. Clair is in England with her mother. She’s on her way to Switzerland for an abortion. She’s a college sophomore, unmarried, and her parents have decided that the way to handle her unplanned pregnancy is to remove it.  What she really wants, however, is to find her cousin Rose, who disappeared in France during WWII. Rose is the only person in Charlie’s family to understand Charlie, and Charlie is desperate to find her.

In 1915, Eve Gardinier is recruited to be a spy for the Allies. She’s stationed in Lille, France, which is near the Belgian border and occupied by the Germans. She speaks French, English, and German, and has one of those faces that looks completely innocent and incapable of lying. She gets a job in a cafe where German officers congregate, eavesdrops on them while clearing their plates, and passes any interesting and useful information on to the British. Her contact is a woman who calls herself Lili, and she has a network of spies and contacts up and down the border, called the Alice Network.

The main theme of the WWI portion is “How can I serve.” Eve, in her life in England, wants to serve her country, but no one will allow her, simply because she has a stammer. Because of the stammer, people assume she’s stupid or mentally disabled. But the captain in charge of running spies in France recognizes her talents and gives her a way to serve. The other women in the Alice Network are in similar positions: this option was the best way they had to help with the war effort. Of course, sometimes the desire to serve, to help with all of your abilities, costs a great deal, and there’s the question if you’re really willing to pay that price. Eve finds herself paying a great deal more than she ever expected, for decades.

The theme of the post WWII portions is related: what is the human cost of all this war and suffering? Eve is still suffering from the psychological (and physical) effects of her service in WWI. Eve has a driver, Finn, a Scotsman who was part of the group that liberated one of the concentration camps, and that experience still haunts him. Charlie, who was in high school during the war, did not serve, but her brother came back a different person, and eventually killed himself. Charlie’s response to that trauma was to try to find a way to feel things again by sex, which did not work out the way she intended.

The trick with a dual chronology is making sure the two stories weave together and come to a climax that complement each other. The other trick is making sure your two timelines are equally interesting. I found myself skimming the 1947 story to get back to the WWI story, which was  LOT more tense. 1947 was road trip through post-war France; 1915 was espionage. Which is more exciting?

Quinn included, probably because she saw me coming, an extensive author’s note talking about how Lili was a real person, Louise de Bettignies, who did everything she does in this book.  I know there aren’t any spoilers in history, but if you don’t know about Louise, and her service record, and you’re going to read The Alice Network, maybe… don’t… read her Wikipedia page? (We didn’t link to it on purpose.) I had no idea how this story was going to go, and I didn’t know that Lili was a real person, so I was on the edge of my seat after the 2/3 mark.

The other thing that I enjoyed was the minutiae of spy craft, such as writing messages on slips of rice paper and winding them around hairpins, or drawing maps on petticoats. Or, ways to sneak past a border checkpoint when you don’t have the right paperwork – all the details are fascinating.

There is a romance. It’s not centered in the plot, it develops very slowly and organically, and the meat of this novel is the relationships between the women. They learn how to become a honeypot, if that’s what is required, how to support each other in the darkest of timelines, and how to continue to live after everything you ever knew was torn away from you.

If you read and loved Code Name Verity ( A | BN | K | G | AB | Au ) this is a book for you. I said a couple of years ago that I expected a lot of World War I stories to come out of this centennial, and I’m pretty pleased to have been right. There are a lot of really interesting stories emerging.  I’m also really interested (for various reasons) in how people deal with the PTSD that come out of traumatic periods in history, and this story is a deeply layered exploration of just that.

This book is available from:
  • Available at Amazon
  • Order this book from apple books

  • Order this book from Barnes & Noble
  • Order this book from Kobo
  • Order this book from Google Play

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
We also may use affiliate links in our posts, as well. Thanks!

The Alice Network by Kate Quinn

View Book Info Page

Add Your Comment →

  1. Dayle says:

    Code Name Verity made me cry, so this one is diefinitely going on the To Read list!

  2. Leanne H. says:

    Code Name Verity made me UGLY cry after joining the Bad Decisions Book Club. So yeah. This is going on my TBR, too. Thanks for the review!

  3. Heather B says:

    I’ve heard so many great things about this one. I’m going to have to check it out. Do you think it would be as good on audio?

  4. Lucy says:

    Lady spies! WWI! Catnip! TBH, a road trip through postwar France sounds pretty fascinating as well. For a book about a lady spy with more romance, you might try Charlotte Gray (which I recommend all the time because it’s just that good.)

  5. book fan says:

    Adding this to my list as well! If you are looking for another WWI book with a dual timeline (though this was WWI and the present day), I highly recommend JoJo Moyes’ The Girl You Left Behind. This book also explores Germany’s WWI occupation of NE France. While I liked the present day story, it could not compare to the WWI story — it was one of the most intense reads I have read in a long time.

  6. Helen R-S says:

    You might enjoy Miss Lily’s Lovely Ladies by Jackie French. It’s set just before and during WWI – the back cover copy says “A tale of espionage, love and passionate heroism”. IMO the espionage wasn’t the biggest part of the story. It’s not a romance with a traditional HEA (or even a HFN), either, but there’s a possibility of a future HEA. I really enjoyed the fact that Sophie was able to evaluate romantic relationships and whether it would work out (e.g. considering issues like her wanting to return to Australia, vs the man wanting to stay in England, rather than just going, “I like him and we’ll make it work somehow”). I’d say the biggest elements are friendships between women, and women doing things (like setting up hospitals for wounded soldiers) once the war began.

    I’m probably not doing a good job of explaining why I liked it, but I enjoyed it and I would recommend it.

  7. Louise says:

    Eve, in her life in England, wants to serve her country, but no one will allow her, simply because she has a stammer. Because of the stammer, people assume she’s stupid or mentally disabled. But the captain in charge of running spies in France recognizes her talents and gives her a way to serve.
    Please tell me the captain had the brains to figure out that if most people assume Eve is stupid, then so will the people she’s spying on, and that’s an asset. Go captain!

  8. Cari Featherstone says:

    Someone asked about audio, I am listening to this book and the narrator is amazing. Listen to it you won’t be disappointed.

  9. Mary says:

    This was a hard book to put down and also difficult to read at times. These women were brave and smart. The conditions they lived under during WWI were awful yet they had a fierce loyalty to one another and to a mission beyond themselves. This book touches ones emotional hot buttons. I wanted to finish the book so my emotions could settle down again!

Add Your Comment

Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

*


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

$commenter: string(0) ""

↑ Back to Top