Smart Podcast, Trashy Books Podcast

316. Sarah and Amanda Talk Book Nesting and Re-Reading Series

Amanda and I catch up now that Amanda has moved into her new apartment – and unpacked probably a thousand books. Then we talk about Amanda’s current adventure re-reading a series she’s not enjoying, but continuing to read.

We discuss the ending of series we’ve started, why we tapped out, and why we sometimes keep reading despite our own preferences.

We ask important questions, such as:

What are your stopping points in a series as a reader?

What makes you stop reading a series – or keep reading it even though it’s not what you expected?

Do you like being surrounded by your books?

And of course, how is reading a series like eating candy corn?

Plus – a sneak preview of an upcoming episode we’re planning.

CW/TW: We discuss assault of characters in the series Amanda is reading at 21:05 for about 1 minute total. 

Read the transcript

↓ Press Play

This podcast player may not work on Chrome and a different browser is suggested. More ways to listen →

Here are the books we discuss in this podcast:

Links! To many things!

First: the Twitter thread that started our conversation. 

Amanda’s and my discussion about television, Episode 308. Sarah and Amanda are Terrible at Watching TV (But We Talk About it Anyway). 

Our adoration for this fan casting by Thalestral of a Dragon Age: Inquisition movie knows no limits nor boundaries.

We also mentioned Library Thing and Sarah’s addiction to the Double Love Podcast, part of the Headstuff Podcast Network. 

And: extra joke!

We’ll We’ll We’ll.

Show Spoiler

If it isn’t Autocorrect.

If you like the podcast, you can subscribe to our feed, or find us at Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows!

Thanks to our sponsors:

More ways to sponsor:

Sponsor us through Patreon! (What is Patreon?)

What did you think of today's episode? Got ideas? Suggestions? You can talk to us on the blog entries for the podcast or talk to us on Facebook if that's where you hang out online. You can email us at [email protected] or you can call and leave us a message at our Google voice number: 201-371-3272. Please don't forget to give us a name and where you're calling from so we can work your message into an upcoming podcast.

Thanks for listening!

This Episode's Music

Our music is provided by Sassy Outwater.

This is “Fishing at Orbost,” by the Peatbog Fairies, from their album Dust.

You can find all things Peatbog at their website, or at Amazon or iTunes.


Podcast Sponsor

The Heiress He’s Been Waiting For

This podcast is brought to you by The Heiress He’s Been Waiting For by Kaitlin O’Riley

Christopher Townsend, one of London’s most eligible bachelors, is in need of a wife – a very rich wife whose dowry can cover the crushing debt he inherited on his father’s death.

Pretty American heiress Sara Fleming would suit perfectly. She’s vivacious, outgoing, and he quite likes her a lot. She seems to enjoy his company as well! But the problem is, she thinks herself in love with some American gold digger she left behind in New York.

Can Christopher show Sara that the awareness that runs between them could easily fan into the flames of unforgettable passion?

First in a new series, The Heiress He’s Been Waiting For by Kaitlin O’Riley is now available wherever books are sold and at Kensington Books dot com.

Transcript

Click to view the transcript

This podcast transcript was handcrafted with meticulous skill by Garlic Knitter. Many thanks.

Remember to subscribe to our podcast feed, find us on Apple Podcasts or wherever you listen to your favorite shows.
Smart Podcast, Trashy Books is part of the Frolic Podcast Network. Find many more outstanding podcasts at Frolic.media/podcasts!
Categorized:

Uncategorized

Add Your Comment →

  1. Becky says:

    After listening to the podcast I HAVE to give Amanda a book recommendation. This is not romance, but it is female led space opera and it is SO SO GOOD. Read the Indranan War series by KB Wagers. It’s starts with Behind the Throne. The first trilogy is done. The second trilogy starts this fall. This series got me out of a reading slump and made my geeky heart sing.

  2. Vivi12 says:

    I also have a space opera romance suggestion; Dragon Variation by Sharon Lee and Steve Miller. I love it so much I’ve read it 3 times in 2.5 years, and went on to read all of Lee and Miller books, though some of the later ones aren’t romance.(Another non romance I love is Sunshine by Robin McKinley)
    Super questionable series I have reread against all reason is Kristen Ashley ‘s Mystery Man and Motorcycle Man – though I managed to stop there. I can’t expect lain why, and now I’m wondering if I need to revisit them…

  3. @Amanda says:

    Thank you both for the recommendations!

  4. Gail says:

    Enjoyed this podcast. Thanks for showing me what NOT to read, lol. I must say that I mostly avoid long series. My last being Black Dagger Brotherhood which I tapped out of approx 8 books in. I guess I just want something new rather than a seemingly endless ongoing sessions with the same characters.

  5. Paige N. says:

    I also dislike the Anita Blake series and didn’t even try the Merry Gentry. I read up to Obsidian Butterly and quit because I felt there were a lot of choices made in that book that didn’t enrich the story or the series at all and were there for shock value. I have a bit of rant with that whole series and some of the premises, but I won’t go into it here because it is involved.

    I gave up on the BDB after Qhuinn and Blay’s story because I felt she kept messing with everyone’s HEA which is a bit of a dealbreaker for me. And I still read the Plums because they’re like marshmallows. Fluffy, light, and delicious.

    Oh, I *loved* America’s Sweethearts. It’s corny but hilarious.

  6. EC Spurlock says:

    I moved last year and am still sorting through my books/my late husband’s books and deciding what to do with them all. But I currently have in my living room three boxes of books to go to the used book store, four boxes of contributor copies of needlework books, 3 boxes of YA and two of family history reference, plus two already filled bookcases. Every time my landlord comes in his eyes boggle and he says “You have a LOT of books!” And I want to laugh because he doesn’t even know about the three full bookcases each of my sons has in their rooms, the three more boxes plus my TBR in my bedroom, the six more boxes in the basement room, and god knows how many in storage in my friend’s garage.

  7. Another Anne says:

    Good thing I was listening at home alone while cleaning and not on the metro with headphones. Yes, I was one of the listeners yelling “Morelli” during the Stephanie Plum discussion. I think I stopped reading that series around 12 or 13.

    Although I have culled my books considerably, I still have a very large collection. Some are old favorites, others have meaning because they were gifts or were inherited from family members. I’m in my 50s, but I’ve started to dupe my physical library on kindle, because at some point in my life I’m going to have to downsize and I’d like to avoid a painful discussion with my nieces and nephews about how the nursing home will not allow me to keep boxes of books under my bed. The kindle makes it easier to be a book collector because it is virtual. I tell my family that I am a “collector” of books. We don’t use the “h” word in my household.

    When I was a child, I loved to read series: Nancy Drew, The Bobbsey Twins, Narnia, the Oz books. As I got older, I found that if I liked a book I would want to read the sequel(s). I also felt obliged to read a series in order.

    As I got older, this changed. The first author that I remember this happening with was Anne Rice. I was a teenager when I read Interview with a Vampire and loved it. I remember being excited to hear that there were sequels in the late 1980s and read the next two quickly. Then I read a couple more, but eventually I lost interest in reading the next installment of her vampire books and just stopped. I still own the first 4 books of the Vampire series.

    I’ve gotten much better about dropping a series or skipping through it. I will also start in the middle, if a book comes highly recommended. I started the Pennyroyal Green series in the middle and although I ended up reading the entire series, some of it was a slog. Its a good thing that I liked What I Did for a Duke so much, or I never would have gotten past book 1.

    If an author is able to develop some interesting secondary characters in the first book, I’ll stick with a series long enough to get to the HEA for the characters that I like. This happened to me with Lauren Willig’s Pink Carnation series. I struggled with several books in the middle of the series, wanting to find out how the series ended.

    I’ve continued to read the Outlander series (I started when there were just 2 books), but the last couple books have been a challenge to finish and I have not re-read them. I used to re-read the prior books before I would start the newest one, but I stopped doing that at least 2 books ago and find that I don’t have any interest in re-reading. I haven’t decided whether I will buy the next one, whenever it is published. I think it will probably depend on what else is out there.

  8. MaryK says:

    I really miss my book nest! I haven’t gotten around to unpacked my books since I moved and not having my books around me has started making me edgy. Even though I like ebooks and read both, paper books are like a security blanket for me.

    I prefer to fall behind in series so I’m always catching up, that way I know ahead of time if things are going to go south. It served me well in the Sookie Stackhouse series. I was able to stop at book four and preserve my illusions.

  9. Ellen says:

    I quit the Carparthians around Dark Storm when the world building of Book 2 is completely ignored to make the heroine a part-Carpathian and more powerful than her ancestor when in book 2 being half makes you basically be dying. Even then I read almost four books after.

    Feehan has a bad habit of this tbh and I’m not sure how much longer I’ll be able to read the GhostWalker books.

    Also talk about misogyny, I think they have more now *and* I have less tolerance now.

  10. MaryK says:

    FYI – I’ve read two of the books included in Dragon Variation, and it sounds to me like Daav might be “Amanda catnip.” Don’t get too invested in his relationship arc though. I’m just sayin’.

  11. Katie says:

    I definitely support going back to the Psy Changeling series. And Heart of Obsidian was so great. I only started the series this year, so I had the happy experience of plowing through something like 13 books without having to stop for anything except library availability. It was fantastic.

  12. Katie says:

    Huh. Clearly I just shouldn’t attempt italics with HTML.

  13. mischa says:

    OMG the Sookie Stackhouse books. I made it through the second last one and I just couldn’t bring myself to read the last one. I’d been struggling with the series for a while and had no further fucks to give. When I read the summary of the last book online I was so glad I didn’t read it because I would have been pissed.

    I bailed on Stephanie Plum because I was over the slut shaming and how Steph never actually had any character growth. I stuck with Anita Black a lot longer than I should have, tapping out after number 15. Should have done so after number 9.

    Aside from the books just not being as good, another thing that stops me from reading a series is changing the POV partway through. I stopped reading one series (can’t remember which one) because it changed from first person to third person. Third person doesn’t bother me, but I was so accustomed to reading the series in first person, I just couldn’t do it anymore.

  14. mischa says:

    Blake. Anita Blake. Dammit.

  15. The LibraryThing app was mentioned as a way to catalog books, and a big help while shopping. I use the Goodreads app for the same reasons. You can scan barcodes and covers to look up books/catalog. I’m curious if the LT app has any advantages over the GR one. I have a LT account, but rarely use it. I’m not as much of a fan of the website compared to the GR site. Probably because I haven’t taken time to get to know every little thing about it.

  16. Tee says:

    I’ll continue a series if the first book is worth at least two and half stars. If the second is three I’ll continue. However, if I get further than that I’ll end up finishing which is how I ended up reading all of Sookie Stackhouse which truly…degraded in quality towards the end.

    I do the candy corn thing with eggnog. Every year I say: what a holiday treat! Then taste it and “Oh my God how do people drink this cursed thing. What a horrorshow. I’ll never drink it again!” Next year: Maybe I just imagined it…

  17. karen h says:

    Thank you for this!!

    I too re-read series even when I don’t like the series. I like Amanda’s description that the book description sounds good so you try it again (even though you know it isn’t good and there isn’t a way for it to change). Usually, for me, there is someone that I like and re-reading feeds my imagination when I put the book(s) down and I come up with an alternate ending.

    I’ve also given up on popular series and always felt defective (why are there 20 books to a series that should never have made it past 5??). Every one of those series are listed here, so at least I’m not alone!

    I do have a ton of “real” books (and we’ve moved crossed state lines, multiple times – I have a hard time giving a book away). When I got my Kindle years ago, I’ve never looked back. I *LOVE* electronic books – being able to stick a library in my purse is just too good to pass up! Interesting to me, my daughter is the exact opposite – she must have real pages.

  18. @SB Sarah says:

    @karen h: that’s exactly my situation, too. I love digital reading for the comfort of adjusting the text size, but both my children love reading on paper. It’s so interesting to see the differences and the shifts in preference!

  19. Ren Benton says:

    I could only take what would fit in the back of a pickup truck when we moved, so I had to cull the paper books to one box of hardcovers (a few reference, Harry Potter, Dark Tower) and treasured mass markets. They’re still in a box in the closet because I’m a vagrant and don’t have shelves. I do miss the sight of books. There are several advantages to digital, but there’s no comfort in them.

    I was born without optimism. I tried for decades to overcome my deficiency with regard to books, so I can say from experience that when they’re bad, THEY DON’T GET BETTER. That thing you hate only ever gets WORSE. It’s an immutable law of the bookiverse, and you are only orchestrating your own suffering by persevering. The ghost of Ed McMahon does not appear with a check for a million dollars when you get to the end of a reading ordeal, which could drag on for YEARS the way most series get extended beyond any reasonable life span. It’s okay to be a quitter, letitgo dot gif, and reclaim your time.

  20. Kareni says:

    A few more books for Amanda to consider ~ S.K. Dunstall’s Linesman books (you might say that there is a very VERY slow romance that develops over the three books); the authors’ (two sisters) new book is also a fun read: Stars Uncharted. Also Michelle Diener’s Class 5 series starting with Dark Horse.

    I enjoyed the allusions you made to Anne Bishop’s The Others series but didn’t see any of her books in the visual above.

  21. QOTU says:

    Y’all, don’t hate me, but Anita Blake is actually improving again. (Not back to beginning, but a new thing that is readable and enjoyable if you can deal with a poly relationship in your book). Anita is in therapy and is moving on from the slut shame. Which is why I stay with series even when they lag: optimism! But, serious skimming is totally allowed…

    Not a Romance, really ( also heroine does find a partner in the series), but I am 23 books in on Donna Andrews’ Meg Langslow mystery series. They aren’t all home runs, but they are comfortable for lazy reading, on a slow brain-off day.

    Amanda, if you like space opera, check out Elizabeth Moon Serrano series or David Weber Honor Harrington (but don’t read past about book 4/5 – does degrade).

  22. Karen H near Tampa says:

    So many things going on in this podcast so my response may not match the order (I don’t listen but read when the transcript gets posted so cannot respond until then). Like Amanda, I love candy corn and cilantro, but unlike her I hate black licorice (and red, too).

    I have 6 full-width and one half-width tall (IKEA Billy) bookcases filled with mostly paperback books going back to the late 70s (even though I didn’t start reading romance until the mid-90s) and I have read most of them. I don’t reread but I do collect covers with gorgeous men (yes, I am a Fabio fan and actually started reading romance because he was on a cover) and I consider them to be an art collection that I pull out periodically to admire. But I have cut way back on purchasing print books because I prefer the old artist-drawn covers to the current crop of photos of heavily tattooed and bearded hunks, I don’t want to have to buy another bookcase, and I’m trying to start de-cluttering my house. The books will be the last to go but I know I cannot hang on to them forever.

    I have bailed on two series. One by Susan Squires because I couldn’t take a another book where the hero was tortured so long by a set of females (different females and different reasons but it made me wonder about her husband). The other series I quit was Sherrilyn Kenyon’s Chronicles of Nick because I’ve gotten too old to deal with all that teenage angst. I will agree, however, that her League series is difficult to read but I skim a lot. And, the original versions of the first couple of books were much less intense and, to my mind, much more enjoyable that her revised and retitled versions. I’m still reading the Dark Hunter series though I could hardly get through Acheron. I’m just not in to torture porn. I do skim series more now because while I really loved the early books, some authors have a writing style that doesn’t change and is getting annoying (I hate to say Stephanie Laurens but it’s true). I have also skipped individual books in series by authors I like if the main characters don’t engage me. So far it’s only been one book in several series where I have read all the other books but while I have a strong completist streak, I can beat it into submission these days. I’ve decided life is too short to be annoyed by what I’m reading.

  23. Antipodean Shenanigans says:

    This is relevant to my personal current events. We are moving to a place with 6 metres of tall Billy bookcases. I’m still going to setup a personal reading nook with my TBR and a chair and a place for tea.

    Lindsey’s Mallory series is the one I just can’t quit. I started with one of the latest ones from the library, then went back and started again with Gentle Rogue (I love you James Mallory). The series has some major consent issues, but I just can’t quit it!

    I tapped out 250 pages into the fifth Outlander book. I just didn’t care that much anymore. I’ll keep watching the show though.

  24. Jivi says:

    The League! All 11(?) of them, I keep reading them and rereading my favorites. Most are completely torture porn,-Darlings book- but I still read them as soon as they come out. I don’t know why. I gave up on the dark hunters after Stixx. Loved that one book as much as the League but didn’t care about reading any more of the dark hunters.
    When I stop caring about what happens to the next character that’s when I stop. So, Dark Hunter, Stephanie laurens, Black Dagger, In Death, Kresly Coles (mostly).. Also when the writting or story keeps falling into the same pattern.

  25. Maeve says:

    As someone who has read and own all of the Liaden books in multiple formats, I second (or third) the recommendation for the series. There are multiple romances over the various character arcs.

    You should also check out the old-but-good Mageworlds series by Deborah Doyle and James MacDonald. It starts out a bit like a Star Wars-esque universe but diverges in very interesting ways. Paper copies are hard to find but they are available in ebook format.

    If you’re ok with military sci fi, maybe Tanya Huff’s Confederation series? The main protagonist has a romance starting in book 2 and she’s amazingly competent at her job.

  26. San says:

    Whooooo Space Opera! 🙂

    I really enjoyed The Empress Game series by Rhonda Mason. It just wrapped up the trilogy this summer. I wasn’t expecting much when I grabbed the first one on a whim, but it ended up being a 4 star overall series for me. It does have a -series- long arc for our main couple. Book two does have some dark stuff with a group of secondary characters who have been kidnapped and many different types of nasty things happen although they aren’t all detailed out a lot on the page. Even implied as they are though, that could be iffy for some people.

    Also, even though this next one wasn’t really for me, you may like it better, since you mention Rey-lo. There is a very carefully legally-distinct, why-no-this-totally-isn’t-them book called Black Moon Rising by Frankie Rose. It was not at all what I wanted from it when I read it, but knowing before you start that it’s one careful step away from SW fanfic might make it just the right thing for you.

  27. @Amanda says:

    Once again, thank you all for the recs! <3

  28. Kari Dell says:

    As a person who bought a two hundred dollar piece of abstract art because it is so totally Cabeswater, I loudly second Amanda’s roommate’s love of Maggie Steifvater’s Raven Cycle series. If only I could attach a photo…

  29. Kate says:

    After having to deal with my mom’s book hoard and moving myself into a tiny apartment, I’m much better about getting rid of books now. I mainly hang on to TBRs that get weeded out when the mood strikes and sentimental stuff. I usually only reread children’s books and am very sad that my current collection is in storage so no nesting for now 🙁

  30. Dani says:

    I’ve moved about 3 years ago, and I’m in the midst on another right now. I culled my collection pretty well in 2015 when I sat down and really evaluated why I was keeping my books. It wasn’t necessarily because they were awesome, but because I loved the memories of loving them. I got rid of a lot of them then, but now it’s doubly hard to let more go because this was the trimmed down collection from then. The only consolation is that I’m finding now that my tastes have changed so much that my old favorites just don’t cut it for me (Patricia Briggs and Ilona Andrews notwithstanding).

    Kenyon’s Dark Hunters were a favorite of mine when they first came out and I read them religiously for years. It was Acheron’s book that really turned me, and the knowledge that Nick’s story was being pushed off in favor of a YA series of 15+ books that cemented my decision though. Life is short. I don’t want to be waiting for 20 some odd years to find out about my favorite characters as adults.

    I LOVED Nalini Singh’s Psy series, but once it hit Kiss of Snow I just couldn’t do the will-they-ever-get-together thing. I’m not the most patient, but I really disliked that we’d just get an inkling of amazing from some new characters and they wouldn’t be featured for 12 more books or whatever. I loved the drama with the Council, but couldn’t sit through all the new iterations of story arcs. I do still re-read a few of the very first ones because they are awesome and make me happy.

    Totally gave up on Feehan after the 1st Carpathian…the alpha-hole instalove was just too much for me. Tried Laurell K. Hamilton but just didn’t love the Anita Blake books after they became porn (NOT erotica, but porn), and the Merry Gentry books always left me feeling like I got lost in a game of Twister but with her sexual partners (insert so and so’s A into Merry’s B and turn left for…). Ugh. Too much mental gymnastics trying to get the sexual logistics down. I loved Kresley Cole’s Immortals After Dark for years, but waiting, and waiting, and waiting for Nix’s book has turned into a 10+ year endeavor. I did love her Russian series though, but sadly that looks like it’s done too. I gave up on the BDB after it became more of a drinking game for brands than a romance. I’d pick them up for years thinking they would get better, but when I sat down a few years ago to catch up and re-read them they had no sparkle. I collected the entirety of Lisa Kleypas’ backlist over the years, but gave up on reading the historicals pre-2008. I LOVED Linda Howard so long, and after Cry No More just couldn’t get into them. For years I re-read the entirety of Suzanne Brockmann’s 2 SEAL series, but I couldn’t finish the last one with Izzy’s story. For the better part of 6 years I waited for the end to Justin Cronin’s Passage trilogy, and have yet to finish the last one.

    I used to be guilty of book hoarding. I’d read a book from an author or see a review that was favorable and want to read the series, and collect the series for YEARS. I did this for so many books, and spent SO much money, and in the end when I finally had time to read them, I’d either outgrown them or didn’t like them. My local thrift was so happy with my 23 boxes of brand new/like new book donations, almost all urban fantasy or paranormal romance. Now though, I really don’t have a particular genre that I feel invested in. Where I live almost all the bookstores have closed in the last 5 years, and what’s on the shelves at WalMart and Target is nowhere near my varied tastes.

    One great thing about moving is that I’m re-evaluating what makes a book a keeper for me. I’ve found that I keep very few series of books, but I’ll keep one or two by each author. I discovered over 10 copies of The Princess Bride in 2015 in my collection, and this move I found about the same number of copies of Fahrenheit 451 in various editions.

  31. Lexica says:

    If there’s a series completionist in your life, do NOT let them start reading the War Against the Chtorr books by David Gerrold.

    Or maybe do, if you dislike them. 😉

  32. JenM says:

    I have another recommendation for Amanda – The Paradox trilogy by Rachel Bach, starting with Fortune’s Pawn. Space opera with a strong lead female character who rescues herself, thank you very much.

    I also wanted to say that although I’ve switched 99% of my reading to my Kindle, I can’t seem to give up my urge to collect and hoard paperbacks. It drives DH a bit crazy, because I never seem to actually get around to reading them, but it just makes me happy to see them. I do try to confine them mainly to our spare room but every 6 mos or so, I’ll look around, realize they’ve leaked out to all other available surfaces, and then I corral them all back to the reading room, only to start the process all over again LOL.

    Thanks for another enjoyable podcast!

  33. Emily Nagoski says:

    Y’ALL. I had this insight while listening:

    I totally used to feel like I had to finish a book or a series no matter how much I hated it. Totally, “I started it and I’m going to finish it.” It felt like an unshakable part of my personality that I START WHAT I FINISH, as if finishing something that causes me suffering were a virtue.

    These days? No. No. And here’s the insight: it’s like how I learned to break up with romantic partners who didn’t make me feel great. There’s no virtue in “seeing it through” when “it,” whatever it is, whoever it is, makes you feel shitty.

    I now feel comfortable abandoning a book at any point if it no longer feels that it is contributing to my quality of life. Life is too difficult to tolerate stories or lovers who don’t make you glad they’re in your life.

    I get why people do it. It’s educational to stay with discomfort. But these days? No.

    I should note this change of reading habits dates to about November 2016.

  34. @SB Sarah says:

    @Emily: Oh, wow. I have been thinking about your comment since I read it. There is no virtue in seeing something through if it makes you feel shitty, it’s true.

    “Life is too difficult to tolerate stories or lovers who don’t make you glad they’re in your life.”

    I might have to cross stitch that on a banner for my wall.

  35. Dena says:

    I second JenM’s recommendation of the Rachel Bach books and also the earlier Liaden books (although that’s a series that I’ve almost given up on).

    Another recommendation: for great standalone science fiction romance try Linnea Sinclair. The science fiction is great and the romances are great.

  36. Iolanthe95 says:

    The Liaden books are great. There are a lot of them though and they sprawl over multiple time periods. Agent of Change and its 2 follow-ups are some of my favorite books of all time. I love Val Con & Miri. YMMV. There are more than a few couples and different readers have different favorites.

Add Your Comment

Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

*


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

$commenter: string(0) ""

↑ Back to Top