In this week’s podcast episode, we’re looking at the book reviews for the December 2015 issue of Romantic Times, aka RT Book Reviews.
Special and massive thanks to Shannon Stacey for sending me this issue!
You can also find all the RTRW content at our category page for Romantic Times Rewind.
And, most importantly, if you want to listen and follow along with this entry, we have more detail in the audio, but you can click play and listen and read and absorb all the visual goodness:
Ok, let’s get started with…THE COVER.

That’s Sweetest Scoundrel on the cover there, with the yellow dress, which is book nine in the Maiden Lane series.
Let’s get started with the reviews in this issue!
Historical
There were a lot of reviews that were minimal in content and we found them very frustrating. This review for A Whisper of Desire was one of them:


I guess if you like Regency you might like this? What kind of negging is this?! How is this 4.5 stars?
The cover is pretty mullet-y, too.
Amanda took a look at the review for The Striker by Monica McCarty:

A lot of word salad there.
But hey, if you’re looking for what Amanda calls, “what if Navy SEALs were Highlanders?” There are a BUNCH of books in this series!
Contrast those two with this review, for a book that got 2 stars:

I understand why that book received two stars from this reviewer. The other reviews seem very disconnected from the star rating.
Mainstream Fiction
Amanda was confused by the review and the summary of Girls Who Travel by Nicole Trilivas:

Continuing with the word salad cliche: Branching Out by Kerstin March:

The cover is very of its time, too:
Teen Scene
Where New Adult reigns supreme!
Amanda discussed Light of Day by Allison Van Diepen:



I was delighted by a character name from This Raging Light. DELIGHTED.

Inspirational
Inspirational romance remains the top location for really cool character jobs!
I was extremely excited about the review for Until the Dawn by Elizabeth Camden:


She’s a volunteer weather observer squatting on the roof of his house. I LOVE IT. HECK YEAH. It’s not an obsession with boilers, but it’s up there!
Amanda wanted to talk about Romance by Design by Gail Gaymer Martin:

But there are two covers, and they are BOTH GREAT:

Those are colored contacts, right?
Amanda also noticed this absolutely gorgeous cover:

Whoooooo that’s pretty.


![]()
The question with inspirationals, as Amanda puts it, “What’s the JBV of this book?”
Mystery, Suspense, and Thriller
Amanda had a delightfully thorough rant about Dean Koontz, based on this review:



I read this section actively looking for books to read and I found one!

Death Comes to Kurland Hall by Catherine Lloyd is book three, and the whole series is available in audio and digital format at Hoopla.

The first book, Death Comes to the Village, is like if Rear Window were set in a rural historical village in England. I’m really liking the audio!
Science Fiction and Fantasy
LOOK at that cover for Warlords and Wastrels. WOW. The covers for the whole three-book series are stunning.

Amanda has very strong feelings about how much this review for Mira Grant’s Chimera spoils the series a fair amount, so it’s behind spoiler tags.

There’s a reveal as to what or who the villain is, and Amanda has a lot to say about the way in which the magazine reviews later books in series. This problem comes up again in this issue, too!
Romantic Suspense
We had really not a thing to say about any of the reviews.
Contemporary
There are THIRTY-FIVE BOOKS in this section. Contemporary seems healthy! Don’t think we need to save it or anything.
This review for I’ll Be There by Samantha Chase left me very confused as well:


Amanda wanted to discuss the 4.5-star Top Pick! for The Harder You Fall by Gena Showalter:

Paranormal Romance
Paranormal romance’s review section featured a LOT of powerhouse names in the genre:

Amanda was not into the hero from this review for Disciple by Jody Wallace:


The cover art is wild!

Meanwhile, I had no idea ANY of this happened:

I had NO idea there was a BDB spinoff called Blood Kiss, but as I mention in the episode, I was moving house that month and I had a lot going on. No idea there was a spinoff. None. I am still amused.
We take a side trip into the Black Dagger Brotherhood series, and I mention my review for Lover Revealed, which was largely about how bizarre the series got.
Urban Fantasy
There were five books total, all between four and 4.5 Top Pick! Again, a narrow range, regardless of how many books in a genre section.
I mentioned the review for Alien in Chief by Gini Koch, which is book SIXTEEN in the series and spoils pretty much the whole thing.


Amanda recalled that we’d already discussed this series, because the heroine is named Kitty Katt Martini. Amanda also pointed out another review for a connected sequel, this time Wicked Ever After by Delilah S. Dawson, which features a character named Criminy Stain.


Jiminy Christmas? No, Criminy Stain!
Series
We had a lot of fun in the series reviews! I wanted to talk about A Princess Under the Mistletoe by Leanne Banks, because this guy is maybe 17 at most.


Look at this guy:

The Santana with Rob Thomas song Smooth was written about his face.
There is also a GREAT BIG HAT!

That is a great hat. His cravat is nice, and her dress is pretty great, but THAT HAT.
Amanda and I debated word choice and bonkers-level for the review of Triplets Under the Tree by Kat Cantrell:


That kid on the right is very not impressed.
Erotica
There’s a much more robust range in this section, with reviews at 2 stars all the way to 4.5 top pick. I wanted to talk about Coming Back by Lauren Dane:

The covers for this series are stunning.
Amanda took a trip into Stepbrother Mine by Opal Carew:

That was A. LOT.

And that’s the last of the books we discussed as we read all the reviews in this issue.
Our next episode will examine the advertisements and features in this issue, and that’ll air on January 26!
And remember, if you join the Patreon, you’ll get access to the entire issue as a PDF. ALL THE UNICORN COVER PDF YOU CAN HANDLE.
What do you think? Have you read any of these? Which would you recommend? Do you remember the heyday of mid-2010s paranormal romance?











You mention that back issues of romantic Times magazine are hard to find. I have many issues in my collection that I have kept in storage. If there is anyone out there who wants back issues of their own, I would be happy to help. I checked Ebay and there aren’t any there to purchase, which really surprised me.