You did it! We figured this one out! It is a truth universally acknowledged (by me for certain) that the Bitchery pretty much knows everything, and really, it's true. Scroll down to see the solution for this HaBO - and many thanks!

This HaBO comes to us from Nikki, who is hoping to locate this romantic suspense:
I want to say that I read this book 7-12 years ago, but the book could have been older. This book is a contemporary romantic suspense type book.
The main plot involves a psychic helping and a cop solve a string of murders by a serial killer. Some specific details include: at the beginning the psychic sees herself arriving to the bank too late…it is closed…she leaves early but gets picked up by a cop (the hero) for speeding or something (making her late). She had apparently called the police providing some clues on a murder and the cop that picks her up (the hero) is looking at her as though she is crazy.
Some other specifics: the hero’s father (who was also a cop) has died prior to the start of the book, the hero has a big-ish family of only his mom (who, if I remember correctly has some psychic abilities too and sees the heroine as the hero’s soulmate) and sisters.
The heroine can link into the killer’s mind and provides clues throughout, but in the end the killer is the hero’s captain…and he also killed the hero’s dad. There is the big reveal at the end with the captain trying to kill the heroine with the hero and heroine prevailing.
I know psychic heroines and law enforcement heroes are pretty popular, but hopefully this one stands out to someone.

@Susan:I keep checking too, this one really bothers me and I need it to be solved!
Dina McCall was a good guess, I really enjoyed her book The Survivors about a plane crash in the snowy mountains where a physic lives.
I KNOW I read this an d recently too. It was in anthology, definitely. I think one of the other stories was a Tam Lin retelling…Midsummer… Something?
This is KILLING me, because I so rarely know it, and I know I’ve read it. The Sheriff sends the cop to pretend to date the psychic heroine, and the cop/Hero is reluctant at first.
I think I found it!
Man of My Dreams Anthology!!! Maggie Shayne-Daydream Believer.
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/72625.Man_of_My_Dreams?from_search=true
That’s definitely the one I read! And I did think it might have been from an anthology. Other than that i struck out. Good job!
I’m so glad I could help out. I know how frustrating it can be when you can’t think of the title.
😀
Yahtzee!!! That’s it!!! Thank you so much!!!!
I was trying to find it at my library (long gone, apparently) or the ebook (not available as far as I can see), but it’s in another anthology, too, of just Maggie Shayne stories. And Amazon has used copies for .01 plus 3.99 shipping.
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/357789.Sheer_Pleasure