Bitchin' Blog Posts

Savage Moon by Cassie Edwards

by SB Sarah | June 10, 2007 | Sunday at 5:00 am | 100 Comments
F

Title: Savage Moon
Author: Cassie Edwards
Publication Info: Dorchester 2002
ISBN: 0843949635
Genre: Historical: Other

It’s awful. it’s just awful.

Does that sum it up enough? No? You want me to relive the story details for you, to put my brain through the egg beater one more time? I’m already mour stupidur for having read this stinker of a book. But fine.

About two or three weeks ago, anonymous packages started showing up on my porch every few days. Inside each one was a Cassie Edwards novel. Due to this absurdly generous person, I am now the proud owner of Savage Moon, Savage Hope and a few other savage titles that I’m not even going to get up out of this chair to go verify. There are five Savages currently living in my bookshelf. I have them isolated. No telling what contagion they might pass on to the other books.

I mentioned the arrival of these packages of poop in book form to Candy, who, if it were possible to do so over IM, snickered and professed innocence to any idea that Cassie Edwards might need to find a home on my poor bookshelf. Despite the fact that each book bears a sales tag from Powell’s, which last I checked was in OREGON, the same state as presently houses CANDY (and also LILITH so do not THINK you are off the hook, ma’am), I have no concrete proof as to who set me up the bomb.

Then Candy, evil wench that she is, publicly challenged me to a duel of sorts: read a horrid book, write a review. I, of course, was conveniently gifted with a shit buffet of Edwards oeuvre, so why shouldn’t I put myself through the agony of reading one of these savage monstrosities?

Trouble was, I had to pick one. So I picked Savage Moon since the title was funny enough that perhaps laughing at it could give me a small soothing balm of comfort while I poisoned my brain. Alas, the Moon did little to help me. Thus book sucked donkey balls. There isn’t an F low enough to throw at it. I might have to modify our grading schedule and give it a Z except that the poor letter Z did nothing to deserve being permanently stuck on a Cassie Edwards novel.

Let me give you a brief plot summary: Misshi Bradley, who is really named Mitzi but her older brother has a monster of a lisp and can’t say her name so Misshi she is, thereby damning me to think of Misha Baryshnikov, is on a wagon at age 10 heading west. Her parents are dead, her siblings are dead, and the only family member left is her older brother, Dale. As expected, their wagon train is attacked by a renegade band of Shoshone Indians, lead by Chief Bear, who grabs Misshi with her wild red hair, throws her over his saddle, and rides away. Dale manages to get off one shot, which lodges in Chief Bear’s head, completely scrambling his brains, though he does manage to hold onto a squirming 10 year old tossed across his saddle.

Misshi is brought to Chief Bear’s camp but makes her escape in the fuss the others make over Chief Bear’s incapacitated state. Moments before Chief Bear and his comatose self are brought into the camp, however, Chief Bear’s wife helps their only son, Soaring Hawk, escape to form a camp of his own, because he does not approve of his fathers renegade ways. Trust me, he doesn’t approve. He says it about six time in one page.

Ten years later, when Misshi is conveniently 18 years of age, the book reveals that she’s been miraculously adopted by a neighboring Shoshone tribe and made the adopted daughter of the chief. How this was accomplished, no one knows, least of all me because the book didn’t tell me, but Misshi is a happy, dimwitted dipshit of a heroine in the Edwards mold, and has dyed her hair black with some random but powerful weed so she can blend in better with the other Shoshone.

Her adopted father turns out to be something of a mentor to Soaring Hawk, who is now a chief in his own right, and his little band of not-so-renegade-but-yet-renegade dudes has grown and remained safe and happy in their secret location. Soaring Hawk meets Misshi, their respective nether parts burst in to flame, and the obstacles they have to overcome to find their happy ending revolve around the fact that she’s white with red hair. Misshi realizes her appearance as a Shoshone is only skin deep, and she must struggle to find emotional and cultural balance between her old life, her yearning to be reunited with her brother, and her new potential life as a chief’s white wife, even IF the other members of his group accept her.

HA! I’m kidding. Honest appraisal of cultural difference? You are barking up the wrong shit tree. Not here, my friend. The obstacles facing Misshi and Soarking Hawk’s happiness stem from her brother Dale’s having gone batshit crazy while serving in the military. Vowing revenge for the kidnapping of his sister, he dresses as an Indian and attacks Indian camps and wagon trains, scalping and killing everyone in site, and saving the scalps as tribute to his lost sister. As soon as he finds Chief Bear, whom he doesn’t know has had his chiefly brains turned into a cerebral scramble, he plans on quitting his life of bloody crime and going off to St. Louis to be an opera singer.

No really. I’m not making that up.

Since I had to go through the experience of not only reading this tripe but reading it PUBLIC where people on the bus could SEE that I was reading this tripe, I figured, what better way to share my journey through the Cassie circle of hell than to excerpt my very favorite parts of the book and footnote them with my reaction. Hold your mouse over the hypertext and a small window should appear. Let me know if it doesn’t work in your browser.

Journey with me now. But take some Pepto first.

 

"Misshi, you are in such deep thought. What were you thinking about, little sister, that made you smile so sweetly?"
"You, big brother, you."
She reached over and placed a hand on his knee.
"Maybe I'd best not ask what your thoughts were, but you were smiling, weren't you?"

"It tears at my heart to know that such a man has my sister." He would hunt down Chief Bear and kill the savage himself. If... she...was still alive!


...

"Son, your tepee awaits you. Foods that you kill will cook over the flames of the fires. I have taught you not only how to be a strong leader with the right morals, but I have also taken the time to teach you the art of cooking, since you and your braves will not have mothers, or daughters, or even cousins to cook for you."

When she saw the lifeless body...she knew the one lying there was her husband. Signing with relief, for she did love the man no matter the havoc he wreaked everywhere he went, she fell to her knees.

He was devoted to his small group.... And with a woman by his side, giving him the nourishment of her love, could he not be twice the leader he was said to be today?

My heart is heavy. I cannot put everyone in danger only because the boy in me wants to go to my mother.

...

Misshi signed happily. She had adapted well to life with these kind Shoshone. She had even dyed her hair black with the stalks of a root called we-sha-sha so that she could look like an Indian. She was so very fond of her life as an Indian maiden that she was averse to the idea of going back to live in the white world.

"It seems that fate today has arranged that you and my adopted daughter should finally meet. Perhaps it is the will of the spirits. I am not one to argue with fate."

...

"My son is too astute to take such bait.... He is a man who prays and whose prayers are answered. In his prayers he sees his mother well and strong."

...

He had to see to Chief Bear's demise. Of late he had discovered he had a talent for singing. He couldn't help wondering how it would feel to perform before an audience in St. Louis's beautiful opera house.

...

He was sure she had feelings for him, and that knowledge made his loins ache with need of her. He wanted her with him always!

"Soaring Hawk, is it not time for your blankets to be warmed by a woman's body? Does not Misshi stir your loins?"

She gasped, embarrassed by Washakie's openness in speaking about Soaring Hawk's loins!

But nearby, glittering evil green eyes watched them from high above, soon to make a beautiful moon become suddenly...savage.

Because life was harsh here in Wyoming land.

...

"Do you truly think I can learn how to ride a horse again?"
"You will ride, you will feel the freedom of riding, and you will feel the joy it brings to your heart."

"When I wish to be alone with my prayers, I come to this secret place. One day, though, it will be discovered by whites."
"It is so beautiful," Misshi sighed.

A blaze of urgency filled her as his tongue continued to pleasure her in a way she would have thought forbidden. But the wild exuberant passion it created within her made her uncaring of society's rules.

"Nei-com-man-pe-ein, I love you, woman," Soaring Hawk said huskily, then crushed her lips with a heated kiss and ground his body into hers until they both moaned.

...

"Those responsible for this kill might be close enough to grab you."
"Then go and I will go with you; I shall keep my eyes closed."

...

He knew that this night would not pass without their coming together as lovers!

In Shoshone and Bannock the North Star is called Wa-se-a-ure-chah-pe, and then there is Ursa Major which his also called the Seven Stars and The Wagon. It makes its revolution around the polar star, pointing toward it. This is the secret of how my people travel by night when there is no moon."

"I love the Milky Way." I love how it is called moch-pa-achon-ka-hoo, the backbone of the sky."

"We also believe the Aurora Borealis is a cloud of fire."

Nothing had stopped Chief Bear's hate until that bullet entered the base of his skull and rendered him almost a vegetable.

Misshi turned toward White Snow Feather. She tried to ignore the resentment in the depths of the woman's eyes.
"White Snow Feather, I can never forget what Chief Bear did to my family, and I'm not sure I can ever forgive him, but if Soaring Hawk can bargain for his release, I will not interfere."
Just that quickly, the antagonism White Snow Feather had felt for Misshi was gone.

His father wasn't even aware when Soaring Hawk could no longer hold back his tears and took Chief Bear into his arms. "Oh, Father, is it I. It is Soaring Hawk who has come to take you home to Mother."

...

"This is our special night. My woman, I have not even played my flute of love for you."

He was proud of her knowledge of the Shoshone way of healing. She knew so much, no Shaman was required to ensure Soaring Hawk's health.

"See the dried material on the very tips of the sharpened stone arrowhead?" Soaring Hawk said, pointing toward it. "The points of these arrowheads have been dipped into a mixture of pulverized ants and the spleen of an animal that has been allowed to decay in the direct rays of the sun," Soaring Hawk said grimly. "This rotten mixture combined with rattlesnake venom is the deadliest of weapons."

Misshi fell to her knees. "Finding these scalps and these arrows proves that my brother has been killing whites and making it look like the work of Indians."

...

"During council, I had a premonition you weren't safe."

"Big brother, who was the true savage! You were, Dale, you were."

"These flowers will help erase the ugliness I just went through."


So there you have it: brain poison, Cassie Edwards style. I have to seriously question WHY this shit is continually published? I know the short answer is that many someones, somewhere out there, is buying this shit. But holy crap in a cover, why? How is it that this superficial, tawdry, poorly-written drivel passes as some sort of tribute to Native American culture? You know the crying Indian commercial from the 70's? He's not crying because he paddled through chemical waste and litter. He's crying because he just finished a Cassie Edwards novel that bastardized his culture into trite homilies and meaningless drivel.

Seriously, the presence of books like this on the market pisses me off. I take it personally that people are writing, marketing, and selling this crap because it is so utterly and completely terrible, it's culturally offensive, it's poorly written, and it's so very much the reason why romance novels have such a bad reputation. It's insulting to Native Americans, and it's insulting to me. F this book, literally.

Filed: Reviews, Grade F, Authors, D-G

| |

Charlene said on 06.10.07 at 05:23 AM

If… she…was still alive!

At least we know who would play the brother.

AnimeJune said on 06.10.07 at 05:48 AM

I can’t see the comments on my computer - what am I missing out on? Undiluted Cassie Edwards quotations! ARGH!

Ann Bruce said on 06.10.07 at 05:51 AM

Cassie Edwards novel = beer?

Like beer, a Cassie Edwards novel will make you a more efficient thinker because, like beer, it kills brain cells.  Hopefully, it’s the weak, slow brain cells that are killed off, thus allowing the brain to operate faster.

Is Darwin rolling in his grave?

Cori said on 06.10.07 at 05:57 AM

...can’t…stop…laughing! (Note the ellipses and the exclamation point. I’m SAVAGE!)

Amy said on 06.10.07 at 06:03 AM

I…cried…savage tears of laughter.

Wirdald said on 06.10.07 at 06:04 AM

After the fourth quote, I couldn’t even laugh anymore. It was too painful. And yet, just like when I sloooowwlly peel off a band-aid, I continue to watch and wince and say, “Ow!” (Not “How!,” which is no doubt the appopriate greeting between any two of Edwards’ “Native Americans.”)

OMG…WTF…BBQ…!! (ellipses for em…pha…sis)

I can’t believe you finished it. Seriously, I am completely impressed. And awed. And, to be honest, a bit disturbed.

Jessikast said on 06.10.07 at 06:27 AM

I’m using Firefox 2.0 and getting no joy with popup boxes. :-(

Ann Bruce said on 06.10.07 at 06:34 AM

Jessikast, do you allow JavaScript enabled on the browser?

I’m using Firefox 2.0 and the pop-ups work just fine.

spinsterwitch said on 06.10.07 at 06:34 AM

WTF was she freaking out about the oral sex about when he’s offering to play his flute of love for her!  Dude.  That is one flexible chief!

K said on 06.10.07 at 06:35 AM

Safari doesn’t like popup boxes either.

Or maybe those awful quotes just wore it out.

Kathleen said on 06.10.07 at 06:48 AM

Ok, wait, maybe this is a very elaborate practical joke.  Like, Candy didn’t buy the books, she hired some gifted comic talent to write the books.  Right?  Please?  Oh God, tell me Cassie Edwards isn’t real.  Let this all be a nightmare.

Teddy Pig said on 06.10.07 at 06:56 AM

So opera singers are actually genocidal psychopathic killers. You learn something new everyday.

Teddy Pig said on 06.10.07 at 06:59 AM

Safari? People actually use that?

I always download Firefox so things actually work like they should.

Jess said on 06.10.07 at 07:36 AM

Damn it! I laughed so hard I was crying. I hate you. No, wait. I love you. Because you reminded me that I bought a used one of her books awhile back, looked at the first page after I got home, said “hell no!”, and booted its ass to Goodwill. Do not stop, do not collect 200. Let someone else read it. So glad I did now, too.

I, just, it. They. WHAT?! God help you. I’m sorry you have this embedded on your brain. *hands over the industrial sized brain bleach container* Might want to use it every several hours until your brain is thoroughly cleaned.

At least you didn’t have to read Cassandra Clare? I’m still hanging my head in agony days later.

Dechant said on 06.10.07 at 07:54 AM

Hey, there’s an idea! SBTB should do Cassandra Clare next!

Lilith Saintcrow said on 06.10.07 at 07:57 AM

I got to the flute of love and started laughing so hard I scared my five-year-old son. He’s traumatized for life by Cassie Edwards. Just like I’m sure Sarah’s traumatized for life.

Dreadful torture, buttercup. But you came through like a trooper.

*rolls off to snorkle-laugh some more*

Leti M said on 06.10.07 at 08:16 AM

I couldn’t read it with Internet Explorer 7 or Firefox 2.0 grrr

I can’t beleive you survived reading that with your faculties intact… you are a stronger woman than I

fiveandfour said on 06.10.07 at 08:33 AM

Wow, you took another one for the team - you Smart Bitches have ovaries of steel.

In the spirit of CSI: Shoshone I might note that the downtown Powell’s is within walking distance of Voodoo Doughnut.  Can’t think how that could be used as evidence.  ::Whistles innocently::  After all, your cleverer breed of troublemaker might use that fact as a diversionary device. 

(Using Safari and everything worked fine.)

Richelle Mead said on 06.10.07 at 08:35 AM

Oh my god.  This review just did more to improve my day than the glass of vodka beside my laptop.

Jenyfer Matthews said on 06.10.07 at 08:52 AM

This if from the Cassie Edwards website bio (just to give you all a heads up):

[...]she still can’t believe that over 99 of her historical romances have been published. Seventy eight of those books are Indian romances. [...]Each book she writes is well-researched and authentic and she is striving to write about every major Indian tribe in America.

Say no to “Savage”

Lisa said on 06.10.07 at 09:01 AM

At least she wrote about the Shoshone, and not the Apache or Cherokee. Yay for variety? Sacajawea would be so proud of her tribe. ::gag::

Wonder if she’s ever written about the Chumash? “He ground into her like his people ground the acorn, or wa-she-sum-pa-doo, as his people called it. And like the acorn, if pounded long enough, the fine dust would lose its poison and become a nurishing food of love.”

No, I can’t do it. How the hell does she write like that for 300+ pages?

Claudia said on 06.10.07 at 09:09 AM

My first and last Edwards was the one about the wheelchair bound lady lawyer. One positive thing I can say is the Edwards has a better website than Suze Brockmann :)

jeanie said on 06.10.07 at 09:21 AM

So, you didn’t like the book?

Oh my, we used to keep copies of that sort of trash in our share house when I was younger, and take turns “dramatising” sections for the housemates.

I shall be sure to avoid the series even if they offer them 3 for 12 at the local newsagent.

Elizabeth said on 06.10.07 at 11:00 AM

My local library just sold a bunch of its old books—a quarter for paperbacks and $0.50 for hardbacks.  I’m glad that I skipped over the Edwards, though I’d read good things of her… apparently not here.  (I did get two old Du Maurier’s, though: “Mary Anne” and “The Loving Spirit”).

Sarah, I admire you SO MUCH.  As much as Edwards admires hyphenating single-syllable phonetic translations of Native American words.  It makes the readers think that they are learning a new language!  Then they feels smartful!  (Though why the characters would then repeat what they have just said, in English, when they both should know the native language, and both of them probably don’t know English…)

Could proximity to such fare be harmful to the baby?  What if he/she grows up begging you to take him/her to Wyoming-land to learn how to play the flute of love?  Or what if the baby develops prenatal memories of eating flowers, and insists that he/she must snack on the garden in order to erase ugliness?

skapusniak said on 06.10.07 at 11:19 AM

If an ‘F’ is simply not a harsh enough rating then how about an ‘F-’?

‘Yea, for even the most despise-ed F shalt disdain thee, and from this day forth the foul mark of her judgement of THE MINUS shalt be born up thy pages, even unto the very end of thy shamed and weeping chapters.  And, yea, upon that day that all shall be brought before the throne of THE LORD, that despise-ed F shall be raised up far above thee, and thou shalt be trampled beneath her feet and for thy pride cast down unto the firey damnations of the pit! Repent! Repent before the moment of thy final hour!’

—Novels in the Hands of an Angry F (SBTB, Intetubes, 1741)

...Or something like that anyway.

December Quinn/Stacia Kane said on 06.10.07 at 12:20 PM

Sometimes I envy the illiterate.

keziah hill said on 06.10.07 at 01:41 PM

I just can’t get past the flute of love.

B.E. Sanderson said on 06.10.07 at 03:38 PM

Thanks for throwing yourself on the grenade.  As horrible was it was for you, it was hilarious for me to read about your pain. 

You heap big brave woman.

Darlene Marshall said on 06.10.07 at 03:59 PM

I was only cackling with glee up until “flute of love.” 

Then…I…wet…my…pants…laughing.

OMG, you so took one for the team.  We can only hope it doesn’t warp the little one for life.

Liz C. said on 06.10.07 at 04:10 PM

I . . . I just can’t believe he talked about his flute of love. I mean I’ve seen the references here, but I’ve never personally read that phrase in any romance novel.

Also, I have Firefox 2.0, I have Java enabled, and the pop-ups still don’t work so I fear I’m missing some quality comments.

Teddypig said on 06.10.07 at 04:25 PM

The only thing I can think to block this would be…

In Firefox go to preferences

select content tab the one with the world on it

check all four boxes

block pop-ups

load images

but especially enable javascript and java

DS said on 06.10.07 at 05:01 PM

I had No-Script enabled—it’s an add-on for Firefox.  Once I disabled that and restarted the program the popups came up fine.

I think AAR was the place where I read about one of Cassie Edwards books where the hero’s first wife died in two different ways.  At one point she drown and then another point she was killed by a bear.

Teddypig said on 06.10.07 at 05:08 PM

I have fallen in love with the spell check in Firefox…

preferences

Advanced tab

General tab

check the box “check my spelling as I type”

I suggest Firefox on both Mac and Windows so you always have the same app on any OS.

Najida said on 06.10.07 at 05:25 PM

I have a suspension bridge of disbelief.  I love Linda Howard, Susan Elizabeth Phillips…I’ve read everything by Amanda Quick.  I hated Putney’s “To Have and To Hold”, and I refuse to read anything with a ‘bittersweet’ ending.  However, I have loved most off Christine Feehan’s stuff.

I have no problem with unclipped Cockzillas in fact and fiction.

I am the Raspberry Koolaid, “It’s SHINY”, ‘well, how are the sex scenes’ romance reader.  I have no concept of prose, little literary understanding and even less taste.

However, what I just read made even my eyes water in pain.  So it must be REALLY REALLY REALLY bad.

It passed the Tacky Tasteless Najida Test.

AnimeJune said on 06.10.07 at 05:55 PM

Sorry! I posted this in the wrong comments…Here goes:

“Flute of Love”? *stolen for own romance novel title*

Flute of Love: “Oboe,” she swore, albeit muffled by her head cold, “I cannot fall in love with a flautist, no matter what his trombone looks like, because bassoon I will be wed to the man who answers my father’s saxaphones at his quick-speed clarinet company!”

“Oh yeah?” he said. “Well, I’ve been trained my entire life how to blow something just the right way while covering all the right holes. Surely those skills can translate to lovemaking! Surely?”

Edit: Haha, my word is enough11. “Enough Cassie Edwards!” I saw one of her paperbacks for 50 cents at my discount booksellers, and I was tempted to buy it because I’ve been trying to read as much romance as possible…thank you for warning me off!

Jackie L. said on 06.10.07 at 05:56 PM

I have the same taste in low literature (low taste in literature?) as Najida but I never made it past the terrible covers on the Cassie Edwards oeuvre.  Thank God.  SB Sarah you are amazing!

Del said on 06.10.07 at 06:08 PM

“Big brother, who was the true savage! You were, Dale, you were.”   What is that exclamation mark doing in there?  It’s not a sentence.  I think it migth be aiming for a question but that’s the wrong punctuation for a question.  *sobs*

If Edward’s is writing about all the North American tribes do you know if she’s wrecked her particular brand of havok on the Navajo and their four genders or the Mahave and their Alyha gender?  The playing of the love flute could get really interesting.

Karla said on 06.10.07 at 06:10 PM

He would hunt down Chief Bear and kill the savage himself. If… she…was still alive! Wait a second he wants her dead?

That was really amazing.  The astronomy lesson just died under the weight of historical logic.  *cries* Why did that have to be in there.

Next up CSI: Shoshone and the spy in the tribe.


Hey Del - I don’t know if she has but the thought of her trying to explain the Alyha or Nadleeh makes me cringe.

sandra said on 06.10.07 at 06:35 PM

Shouldn’t Misshi be the one playing the Flute of Love?  Unless he is one of those really flexible guys who can cross their legs behind their heads, in which case he has a future with Cirque de Soleil.  Hmm, Misshi is ten years old when she is captured, and eighteen ten years later.  Guess she can’t count, either.  Pluverized ants + rotten spleen + rattlesnake vemom = overkill.  And I suppose Mishi is going to volunteer to milk the rattler. (All she has to do is think of it as a scaly Flute of Love.)

Najida said on 06.10.07 at 07:33 PM

PS
I do have some standards.  Really bad covers I refuse to buy (Unless it’s someone I know and like).  So Cassie Edwards has always been a no go for me.

There is a God for the tacky and tasteless :)

Shiin said on 06.10.07 at 07:47 PM

I have a book rec for you ‘The Panther and the Pyramid’ by Bonnie Vanak. It’s better than anything Cassie Edwards writes trust me.

OMG!Magic Red Hair, Houri (the sacred virgins of Allah kind) and Evil FatherxHeroxHeroine (manrape!) love triangles totally pwns bad Savage Indian Romance.

Have a cookie for managing to get through that book you deserve it.

DebR said on 06.10.07 at 07:48 PM

This review had me practically peeing my pants with laughter, but I can’t even imagine actually reading the whole book. Gaaahh! You are either incredibly brave or crazy, Sarah. Or maybe a little of both. :-)

Now if you could just get a case of…Sweet…Savage…Amnesia!!!

Kassiana said on 06.10.07 at 08:10 PM

Oy. They sell Cassie Edwards’ trash in Target stores. I saw one and inspected it with my husband a few months ago, remembering what you’d said about how bad she is. The cover featured a tanned white guy dressed like an Indian. I kid you not. I don’t remember the title or the stupid cover description, but it was a white guy on the cover faking being an Indian.

Curiously enough, while offensive, that kinda fits. Cassie’s clearly a white chick faking Indian.

Dorchester publishes her crap, huh? Well, they also publish Linsay Sands, who (while better than Cassie, because a five year old on crack is better than Cassie) also writes terrible stuff. I see a Dorchester boycott in my future.

Jenyfer Matthews said on 06.10.07 at 08:32 PM

WARNING: She has 78 Native American books published and isn’t stopping until she’s covered ALL THE TRIBES. Be vigilant - just say NO to Savage!!

(unless of course you need a good laugh!!)
LOL

Marissa said on 06.10.07 at 08:49 PM

Holy crap… flute of love, indeed.
I work in a used bookstore, and nobody buys the Cassie Edwards. Once in a while, I’ll take one down and release it into the donation pile. It’s not fair to the donations, but when it’s out of my workplace I don’t have to look at it anymore.

Arethusa said on 06.10.07 at 09:02 PM

I’d really like to meet someone who is an actual Cassie Edwards fan. Come on guys, fess up, one of you likes the flute and astronomical backbone talk. If I admitted by Linda “TRY HARDER. RELAX.” Howard fixation you can—well, no, her books aren’t nearly as bad, but you get what I’m trying to say.

Miranda said on 06.10.07 at 09:51 PM

Suddenly, my idea to change the names and slightly alter the situations in my old Buffy/Spike fanfic and publish it as a romance novel doesn’t seem so far-fetched!

wendy said on 06.10.07 at 10:30 PM

Dear Sarah,
Thank you for this review, and thank you for including the publisher’s name as I now know where to send my manuscript. I have an idea for a novel set in South Africa(I have always wanted to go there and if I sell my manuscript I’ll put by a few thousand towards the trip)during the Zulu wars and as we have tomorrow off work I thought I could write it then. My book deals with a young red-headed girl who has lost all her family except her brother, an army officer who takes her on campaign with him. The big twist is that she gets taken by the Zulu chief during a savage attack (this will also be the name of my book).
I wouldn’t want to spoil the story for you…..........and will just say that Missy (my heroine) finds true love not a million miles from the chief, and Wade (the brother) finds a new career in yodelling.
Off to google Zulu+language.

iffygenia said on 06.10.07 at 11:10 PM

Suddenly, my idea to change the names and slightly alter the situations in my old Buffy/Spike fanfic and publish it as a romance novel doesn’t seem so far-fetched!

That’s a reasonable conclusion when major publishers are putting out this kind of garbage.  Sarah’s closing says it:

Seriously, the presence of books like this on the market pisses me off. I take it personally that people are writing, marketing, and selling this crap because it is so utterly and completely terrible, it’s culturally offensive, it’s poorly written, and it’s so very much the reason why romance novels have such a bad reputation.

Romance and sf/f are rife with fanfic/wish fulfillment/Mary Sue/Gary Stu.  Other genres have them too, but it’s mainly in romance and sf/f that they’re unquestioningly published.  In bulk.  With minimal editing.  It IS embarrassing.

Sana-chan said on 06.10.07 at 11:44 PM

Did anyone else notice that people in this book did a lot of signing?

“Signing with relief…”

and

“Misshi signed happily.”

Was that an SB typo or were the Cassie Edwards version of the Shoshone really big on sign language?

Chris said on 06.10.07 at 11:45 PM

Holy Convoluted Plot, Batman! You lost me after the lisp.

If her work is so well researched then why does her bio say “Indian tribes of America.” Did they sail from India and settle the west? ‘Native Americans’ or ‘First Nation’ might have helped to show that she might know what she’s writing about.

I don’t know how you finished it. Flute of Love? Is that a Flavor of Love spin-off?

carolyn said on 06.11.07 at 12:33 AM

why does her bio say “Indian tribes of America.” Did they sail from India and settle the west? ‘Native Americans’ or ‘First Nation’ might have helped to show that she might know what she’s writing about.

Many tribes still call themselves Indians, e.g.

Delaware (Lenape) Tribe of Indians
Spokane Tribe of Indians

Jess said on 06.11.07 at 01:25 AM

Hey, there’s an idea! SBTB should do Cassandra Clare next!

No, no. The ideas she stole from were better. Trust me. When the not!Peter Pettigrew uses a chakram to attack the not!Remus Lupin, I nearly cried. Not from agony for not!Remus, but because I liked Xena’s take a whole lot better. I wrote a really long write-up on it, and it made little to no sense. I gave it a D+ because if I had lived in a cave the past 30 years, it would have been a really good original book.

Jess said on 06.11.07 at 01:27 AM

Suddenly, my idea to change the names and slightly alter the situations in my old Buffy/Spike fanfic and publish it as a romance novel doesn’t seem so far-fetched!

Miranda, if Clare can do it, anyone can. *grins* Besides I know people who are going to alter their world building fan fic and try to publish them in a couple years.

Melissa said on 06.11.07 at 01:41 AM

Oh Holy Jesus!

Even given the treatment it deserves, that book still manages to both suck and blow.  Although Sara’s take made me giggle loud enough for hubby to turn the TV up.  :)

Sarah, maybe you should go read some Georgette Heyer to scrub it out of your brain?  Or JD Robb?

quichepup said on 06.11.07 at 02:18 AM

I’ve scared the dog with my loud laughing. So much badness but Sarah’s line about the mother-in-law had me spitting at the screen.

This scared me:“she is striving to write about every major Indian tribe in America.”

Oh HECK NO! I hope she doesn’t find out about the Choctaw and Muscogee. We were not known as great horsemen, buff warriors or even time traveling astronomers. We were short chunky farmers who more resembled hobbits than any “savage.”

Wry Hag said on 06.11.07 at 02:28 AM

I’m still pondering the “almost a vegetable” description.  Did the dude become, maybe, a tomato, which is really a fruit but which people assume is a vegetable?  Honestly, this is going to keep me awake tonight.

And the aspiring opera singer…  I kept flashing on images of ear-stabbingly shitty wannabes on the “American Idol” audition episodes.  It never occurred to me people of a bygone era could be as delusional as my contemporaries.  So now, in addition to the “almost a vegetable” image keeping me awake, I’m bumming out about that.

Not to mention the fact (although I guess I’m mentioning it now) I still can’t figure out how precisely to pronounce Misshi

At least now I know who/what to blame for my insomnia.

Kathleen said on 06.11.07 at 04:19 AM

Okay, I investigated my cassie-edwards-isn’t-real theory a little and discovered her myspace page, which is hi-larious.  But even better than the raining hearts and the fact that the internet threw up on her myspace page is her CAFEPRESS STORE.  I shit you not.  Savage Skies wall clock!  The mouse pad!  The coffee mug!  My christmas shopping is DONE, bitches.  Enjoy the mall in December while I sit back, enjoying a nice book (i.e., not anything by Cassie Edwards).
Click my name for her myspace page.  The link to her store is to the right, under the scrolling light-thing, and above the faux-Indian collage.  That’s officially the oddest sentence I’ve written all week.

MamaNice said on 06.11.07 at 04:35 AM

So…much…laughter…can’t…stop…giggling.

Please, oh please, do all your reviews like this.

I have never read an Edwards, but have read a few Native American/white girl romances and the chicks are always red heads (being one myself, I seem to remember that detail clearly). What, so Native Americans have a thing for firewater AND firecrotches.

Speaking of firecrotches, that was the first thing I thought of when the review mentioned Mitzi or whatever had dyed her red hair black. I thought for sure she was going to get it on with some buck who has a WTF moment when he discovers the bear rug doesn’t match the wigwam…or something.

The only good thing this novel’s review has done (aside from provide qualitee entertainment) is encourage me to get off my ass and keep writing. Cuz damn, if THAT trainwreck can get published…

Arethusa said on 06.11.07 at 04:36 AM

Ok, I now don’t know what to do with the knowledge that I could, if I wanted to, make actual contact with real Cassie Edwards fans, for whom she is “the only author I enjoy reading”. I don’t know what to do.

Jess said on 06.11.07 at 05:06 AM

Arethusa, I’d advise running.

SandyW said on 06.11.07 at 08:09 AM

Every time somebody quotes the playing his flute of love bit, all I can think of is Ron Jeremy.

Not a pretty picture.

Somebody needs to figure out who keeps buying this woman’s books. Please, I really need to know.

Maria said on 06.11.07 at 09:44 AM

So does anyone know of any GOOD romance novels featuring Native Americans/Indians?

Just curious.

Lisa said on 06.11.07 at 11:04 AM

I’ve seem to recall liking Dinah McCall’s books as a teenager. They tend to focus on angst and daddy issues, though, so YMMV.

Grace Draven said on 06.11.07 at 03:02 PM

Wow.  Talk about take one for the team. 

That is some serious toxic dreck.  Why, why, why do they keep publishing this stuff?

MeggieMacGroovie said on 06.11.07 at 04:38 PM

Huh, Safari read the bits just fine, with the pop up block intact (HA Teddy!), I just had to scroll over the links and no problems with them showing up.

Oh, and if you google Cassie Edwards, about half way down the page, this review comes up, and just under that, is a link to the comments.

I also found a link to a Harriet Klausner “fan” site, in which the WSJ article is mentioned, and in that, she names two writers she does not like…guess who one was? Yep, Cassie Edwards.
(My HTML sucks, here is the full link)
http://harriet-rules.blogspot.com/2007/05/my-comment-about-hks-exception-to-if.html

Hardly anyone buys her books in my bookshop either, they try to trade them in though, I refuse them, but somehow, I have like 20 titles. Every year, one old woman, at least in her late 60’s comes in and buys some. Once a year….thats it.

Powells romance section is for crap, soo small (its right across from Fantasy, Graphic novels, near the cafe), why do they allow people to trade in Cassie Edwards?? WHY, WHY?!?!?!?!

Stephanie said on 06.11.07 at 04:52 PM

I can’t get the commentary to come up, either, in Firefox or Safari.

If you guys will use the title attribute on the A tags instead of whatever javascript function that is, it might work better for everyone.

Najida said on 06.11.07 at 05:26 PM

I just did an Amazon search, and while Cassie has few reviews, she still has a lot of stars (like 5 for “Savage Dance”) so someone is reading them.

Honestly, while they aren’t my cuppa tea, I can also see how they are ‘emotional porn’ for some…. to borrow a phrase.

Maybe in time the Romance Genre’ can split between that which provides and emotional fix and that which provide literary gold.

I’m beginning to see that the two often aren’t even remotely close. ;)

Najida said on 06.11.07 at 05:35 PM

“an emotional fix”.....

Did I mention I can’t spell for chit?

Dee said on 06.11.07 at 06:05 PM

Oh GOD I needed this. After a night a screaming babies, I really needed a laugh. I read this to hubby, who thought I needed cultural reassurance when I told him, Babe, I can’t EVEN be offended by this book because it’s so horribly bad no one could possibly believe real indians are like this.

(And Sarah, if I knew which flowers those were, I’d send them to you!)

But he, whom we have dubbed Crying Freelancer ever since his two month trip to Hong Kong a few years ago, challenges you to take on the Asian equivalent of Cassie Edwards: Crying Freeman!

Allow me to tempt you with the mystery of the woman who wears a metal electrocution kit she plans to use while, you guessed it, submerged under water with her victim! Will you be able to explain why everyone—particularly people who shouldn’t—get’s naked at the oddest times? Study the various adventures of Yo and Go (nope, I’m not kidding, though Go was pretty bad ass.) and the woman infamously named…Bugnug. Tempting, no? Noooo? LOL!

Dee

--E said on 06.11.07 at 07:39 PM

I, too, cannot get the commentary. Tried Firefox, IE, and Safari—no dice anywhere. Javascript is enabled all over the place. This is a brand-spanking-new Mac.

I feel that I am missing something bedwettingly funny. Sarah, if you ever do this again, I will hunt you down and force you to read every single thing Cassie Edwards has ever written. I WANT THE FUNNY COMMENTARY, dammit, not just the eye-bleedingly bad excerpts from the book!

Kassiana said on 06.11.07 at 08:52 PM

Um…Linda Howard did a better job with Native peoples than Cassie Edwards did (Mackenzie’s Mountain). Of course, Linda didn’t try to do her research by going to the Bureau of Indian Affairs, the group who did its utmost to destroy Native Americans, unlike Cassie…

Poison Ivy said on 06.11.07 at 09:26 PM

Try Kathleen Eagle for reasonable tales of Native Americans. She appears to actually know something about them.

Loved those comments! But I couldn’t bear to keep reading the drivel and had to stop halfway through. It’s just too poisonously bad—and yes, it gives us all a bad name.

Arethusa said on 06.12.07 at 12:33 AM

For those missing out on the javascript commentary, the post right after this has them typed out.

I was kinda hoping this scathing review would stir up some kind of romance blog controversy in which earnest fans would be outraged by Sarah’s spiteful cruelty. I see, they would sneer, why your blog title has the word “bitches”. And others would blog about how online sunshine makes the world go round.

I’m still holding out.

Amy "Fuckheady Bitchipants" E said on 06.12.07 at 12:51 AM

Well, I can CERTAINLY see that half the words in this blog’s header are accurate—TRASHY BITCHES.  Hrumph.  I’m taking my toys and going home.

(mostly, however, I’m LMFAO @ “What a weenus.”)

Amy "Fuckheady Bitchipants" E said on 06.12.07 at 12:52 AM

There, Arethusa, did that help?

Lisa said on 06.12.07 at 01:06 AM

I have never had an occasion to read Cassie Edwards.

I will never have an occasion to read Cassie Edwards. Oh, my poor eyes. I need to rinse them out with bleach. Then scrub my brain with sulfur.

Then I need to go into a corner and quietly weep that people out there still read her books.

Miri said on 06.12.07 at 01:23 AM

Kathleen: Damn you to everlasting DeSalvo slide shows!!!
I clicked, I saw,I threw up a little in my mouth. 
The Bon Jovi
The Hearts
The Collages
The sparkley throbbing flashy…..gah!!
The messages from her “friends”
DeSlavo IS one of the “Friends”
Damn you!

sara said on 06.12.07 at 02:16 AM

OMG FLUTE OF LOVE.

Of all the ignominious names the purple-headed womb ferret has had throughout the generations of romancelandia, that one might be…the…most…demeaning. Maybe…

Freda said on 06.12.07 at 02:51 AM

There may be 78 Cassie Edward titles, but I seriously doubt that she has written more than 5 actual different books.  If you read one Cassie Edward books, you’ve read them all.  I know.  Many, many years ago, I read, I think, 5 of her books.  It was the same story.  The hero was always half-white, and was the only Native American man in the story who wasn’t just a complete savage.

Gina said on 06.12.07 at 04:10 AM

At one point she drown and then another point she was killed by a bear.

Maybe she was washing her face in the river and the bear pounced her from behind? Bears can be bastards like that, the savages.

Arethusa said on 06.12.07 at 05:59 AM

Amy, it did make me smile. Thanks!

Lilith Saintcrow said on 06.12.07 at 06:46 AM

“Purple-headed womb ferret”?

OMG.

*dies*

Kathleen said on 06.12.07 at 07:25 AM

Miri, give it a chance.  At first I hated the Cassie Edwards myspace page, but now I realize how helpful it can be.  When the world spirals into the law of the jungle once more, and natural selection once again rules, these people will be the first to go. 
And DeSalvo is everyone’s friend, if you can avoid the crotch-cooties.

Candy said on 06.12.07 at 04:39 PM

Sarah, I can’t imagine WHY you’d think Lilith Saintcrow and I might be in any way responsible for sending these travesties of taste your way. I can absolutely assure you that at no point were Lilith and I hanging out in Powell’s when Lilith decided you had a drastic Cassie deficiency in your life, and decided to hand-pick and anonymously mail you those books. Nope. Not at all. Never. Because doing that kind of thing would be wrong and awful and terrifying, and Lilith and I, we’d never stoop to such lows.

That said: this is possibly my all-time favorite website book review in the history of EVER. So whoever that person is who sent you those books, I can only bless them for their foresight in the comic possibilities of you reviewing a Cassie novel.

SB Sarah said on 06.12.07 at 05:17 PM

Aw, thank you for the compliment! It almost soothes the savage pain of my eyes having read over 300 pages of this drivel.

Almost.

Your turn is coming.

I’m just sayin’.

LViolet said on 06.12.07 at 08:00 PM

I am screaming. No one can hear me scream.

**This** got published??!?! Now I know for sure that Satan’s pool boy rules the earth. Or at least rules a publishing house.

Somewhere a fiend is laughing.

Zinemama said on 06.13.07 at 08:54 PM

I found your site via Half Changed World and have been popping by now and then. But I’m coming out of lurkdom to say that I’ve never laughed so hard at anything on the internet as I did at your comments on this tripe.  Like a previous poster, I laughed so hard I cried at the “flute of love” bit. Holy moly.

Thank you so much for enlivening the day of a weary stay-at-home mother.

Canaduck said on 06.25.07 at 04:30 AM

Don’t know if this has been said already, because I don’t have the chance right now to read through 88 comments, but the Indian in that commercial from the 70’s isn’t crying because of the pollution OR even Cassie Edwards.  He’s crying because HE’S NOT A FREAKING INDIAN!  http://www.snopes.com/movies/actors/ironeyes.htm

Elizabeth said on 07.03.07 at 01:15 AM

This story remembers me of a friend’s story (who lives in New Mexico)when someone asked her if they still had “Wild Indian Raids”?

I can’t think of the flute of love now without giggling.

Taylor Hartt said on 09.16.07 at 12:26 AM

LMAO !!

I remember reading this, and I remember groaning aloud repeatedly. It was a group read at the time, so I HAD to finish it, otherwise it’d have hit the wall with a satisfactory thud.

Amelia "Fuckheady Bitchipants" Elias said on 10.16.07 at 05:44 AM

Isn’t it time for Sarah to choose a suitably horrific book for Candy to review?  I can’t wait!

Qadesh said on 10.16.07 at 07:11 AM

I was thinking the same exact thing, Amy E.  Bring it on!

Nancy said on 10.16.07 at 08:26 AM

I laughed so loud at your review that I scared the cats, who are still hiding under the bed. I’m never going to be able to look at a flute the same way again!

saltypepper said on 01.15.08 at 07:26 AM

The recent Cassie Edwards implosion makes this review even better, which I would not have believed was possible.

lyricalfool said on 01.18.08 at 09:03 PM

I discovered your site through a presentation in class on plagiarism.

I can honestly say, I came for the drama and stayed for the hypertext. I’ve passed it onto everyone I know who writes and reads.

And I can’t wait to mention it to the C.E. readers at work this weekend.

Thanks for a fantastic site. I laughed the entire way through your book review.

Alyssa said on 01.19.09 at 09:06 PM

This is my first visit to your site, and I am bookmarking you.  This review is AWESOME!!!!!  (BTW, I was directed here through CrankyFitness.com)
I also hate that writers like CE give the entire genre a bad rep.  Her books are so incredibly awful, I thought there were no words.  But you’ve found them, and I thank you!!!!

HRM said on 02.21.09 at 01:52 AM

Owie, owie, owie…the dialog just hurts my brain.

But the background storyline sounds pretty much lifted from the historical story of Cynthia Parker (child stolen by Indians, etc.)

Alex Harman said on 03.18.09 at 11:48 AM

You’re “All Your Base” reference made me chuckle, but the proper Zero Wing grammar isn’t “set me up the bomb,” it’s “set up me the bomb;” the original was “somebody set up us the bomb.”  It’s even more LOL-worthy that way.  As for the book… I’d scream “Oh John Ringo No!” except that it would be gratuitously insulting John Ringo, who’s actually quite entertaining once you get past his paleoconservative politics.  (Of course, when you’ve had the misfortune to read a book by Walter E. Adams, the likes of John Ringo or even Cassie Edwards look like literary giants in comparison.)

Overquoted said on 05.28.09 at 04:32 AM

I knew I should’ve stuck to new posts, knew it. Why, oh why, would you quote all that? You’re evil. I managed to read four of them before I decided shoving something sharp through my skull sounded a lot more pleasurable.

What’s really sad…I know I had to’ve read at least ten of her novels by the time I was 16. No wonder I’m so warped now. Between Literotica and Cassie Edwards, I’m lucky to have a brain left!

Add a Comment

Sorry, comments are now closed for this post.

  • Looking for a book?
    View our past advertisements!